Cannot charge US citizen Matthew VanDyke under UAPA at this stage: NIA chief
The immediate barrier is evidence about who received the training. NIA Director General Rakesh Aggarwal said the agency cannot charge Matthew VanDyke under the UAPA at this stage unless it establishes the identity of the people trained and whether they were Indian insurgents. That matters because the alleged link to Indian insurgents is central to the allegation in the FIR. The NIA says the investigation must identify the insurgents and determine whether any Indian insurgent groups, or their beneficiaries, received training. Aggarwal said the seven had allegedly trained certain insurgents in Myanmar, some suspected of being Indian insurgents. The agency has not yet established that identity or connection, according to his comments. For now, the chargesheet accuses the seven of immigration violations, not terrorism offences. Aggarwal said that if investigators establish the relevant connection, they will charge them. The probe is continuing, and the NIA chief said the agency would pursue legal remedies if VanDyke did not return to India for trial.
Why did the NIA chief say the agency cannot charge Matthew VanDyke under the UAPA at this stage?
The immediate barrier is evidence about who received the training. NIA Director General Rakesh Aggarwal said the agency cannot charge Matthew VanDyke under the UAPA at this stage unless it establishes the identity of the people trained and whether they were Indian insurgents. That matters because the alleged link to Indian insurgents is central to the allegation in the FIR.
The NIA says the investigation must identify the insurgents and determine whether any Indian insurgent groups, or their beneficiaries, received training. Aggarwal said the seven had allegedly trained certain insurgents in Myanmar, some suspected of being Indian insurgents. The agency has not yet established that identity or connection, according to his comments.
For now, the chargesheet accuses the seven of immigration violations, not terrorism offences. Aggarwal said that if investigators establish the relevant connection, they will charge them. The probe is continuing, and the NIA chief said the agency would pursue legal remedies if VanDyke did not return to India for trial.
What charges did the NIA include in its chargesheet, and what alleged conduct do they cover?
The NIA’s September 8 chargesheet accused the seven foreigners of violating the 2025 Immigration and Foreigners Act. The charges covered illegally entering, staying and moving within India. Although the group had initially been arrested under the UAPA, the chargesheet did not include terror charges. That distinction reflects the agency’s stated need to establish more about the people allegedly trained before bringing UAPA charges.
Investigators alleged that the seven entered India on valid visas, then travelled to Mizoram without the required restricted area permit. They were also accused of entering Myanmar and meeting ethnic groups hostile to India. The NIA further alleged that they received drone deliveries from Europe while in Mizoram. The article reports these as allegations, not findings of guilt.
The seven were reportedly arrested in Delhi, Kolkata and Lucknow while trying to leave India. A Delhi court later allowed them to travel to their home countries, then extended that permission until February while the investigation continued. The NIA chief said immigration charges had been brought for the alleged unlawful movements; the agency may add UAPA charges if investigators establish the relevant link to Indian insurgents.
How many people were arrested in the case, and what were their nationalities?
Seven people were arrested in the case: United States citizen Matthew VanDyke and six Ukrainians. The NIA arrested them in March over their alleged role in supplying weapons and military equipment to ethnic armed groups in Myanmar that are hostile to India, and training those groups. The arrests brought together a US national and six Ukrainian citizens in one investigation.
VanDyke leads Sons of Liberty International, a US-based organisation. It says it provides security consulting, training and weapons supplies to vulnerable populations so they can defend themselves against terrorists and insurgents. Investigators alleged that the group had trained armed people in Myanmar, including some suspected of being Indian insurgents. Those allegations remain under investigation.
The seven were reportedly arrested in Delhi, Kolkata and Lucknow while trying to leave India. The NIA filed a chargesheet against all seven on September 8, but accused them of immigration violations rather than terror offences. A court later allowed them to travel to their home countries and extended that permission until February while the investigation continued.
What is the UAPA, and how is it different from an immigration law?
UAPA stands for the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, an Indian law used to address unlawful activities and terrorist offences. The article does not explain the Act’s provisions. As general legal context, it is distinct from immigration law, which governs matters such as a foreign national’s entry into, stay in and movement within a country.
That difference appears in this case. The seven were initially arrested under the UAPA, but the NIA’s September 8 chargesheet accused them of violations of the 2025 Immigration and Foreigners Act. Investigators alleged that they travelled to Mizoram without a mandatory restricted area permit and illegally entered, stayed and moved in India. These are allegations described in the article, not a court finding.
The NIA chief said the agency could not yet bring UAPA charges because it had not established whether the people allegedly trained were Indian insurgents. The agency says identifying those people and any Indian group that benefited is a further part of the investigation. If it establishes that connection, Aggarwal said, it will charge them under the UAPA.
What does the NIA say it needs to establish about the people who were allegedly trained?
The key question for investigators is not only whether training took place, but who received it. NIA Director General Rakesh Aggarwal said the agency must establish the identity of the people trained and whether any were Indian insurgents. He described this as the second part of the investigation. The answer matters because the alleged connection to Indian insurgents is the basis for possible UAPA charges.
The NIA’s account, as reported in the article, is that the seven trained certain insurgents in Myanmar, some suspected of being Indian insurgents. Aggarwal said investigators need to establish whether Indian insurgent groups or beneficiaries of the training were involved. The article does not say that this identity or link has been established.
Until the agency establishes it, the chargesheet accuses the seven of immigration violations rather than terror offences. The NIA filed that chargesheet under the 2025 Immigration and Foreigners Act. Aggarwal said the agency would charge them under the UAPA if it establishes the relevant connection. The investigation was still pending, and the court had extended the seven’s permission to stay abroad until February.
What legal step does the NIA say it may take if it establishes that Indian insurgent groups benefited from the training?
The NIA chief said the agency would charge the accused under the UAPA if investigators establish that Indian insurgent groups, or beneficiaries linked to them, received the training. This is a conditional next step, not a charge already included in the current chargesheet. The agency says the identity of the people trained is central to deciding whether that legal action is possible.
The alleged training took place in Myanmar, according to Aggarwal’s account quoted by The Hindu. He said some of the insurgents trained were suspected to be Indian insurgents. The agency’s next investigative task is to identify them and establish whether any Indian groups or beneficiaries were involved. The article does not report that investigators have completed this work.
For now, the September 8 chargesheet accuses the seven foreigners of violations of the 2025 Immigration and Foreigners Act. The NIA chief said the investigation was ongoing. The seven had court permission to remain abroad until February while the probe continued, and Aggarwal said the agency would pursue legal remedies if VanDyke did not return for trial.
What is an insurgency, and why can the identity of an armed group matter to a country's security laws?
As general context, an insurgency is an organised armed campaign against a government or its authority. The article does not define “insurgent” or state a legal test for identifying one. It does show why the distinction matters in this investigation: the NIA chief linked possible UAPA charges to establishing whether people trained by the accused were Indian insurgents.
The NIA alleges that the seven trained certain insurgents in Myanmar, some suspected of being Indian insurgents. Aggarwal said investigators need to identify those people and determine whether Indian insurgent groups, or beneficiaries of their training, were involved. The article does not say that this connection has been proven. The alleged activity and the identity of the people trained remain matters for the investigation.
The current chargesheet instead covers alleged immigration violations, including entry, stay and movement in India. Aggarwal said that if investigators establish the link to Indian insurgents, the agency will charge the accused under the UAPA. Thus, in this case, the group’s identity could affect whether the NIA pursues the more serious charges it has not yet filed.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web