JupiteX Get the app
International Relations21 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

UK, France and China vote against UAE's Lana Nusseibeh at UN

The brief

The informal poll is intended to help determine who will replace Antonio Guterres as UN secretary-general. Nusseibeh’s support matters because the Security Council’s five permanent members can veto a prospective candidate. The poll offers a signal of support, rather than a final appointment decision. Nusseibeh received seven “encourage” votes, six “discourage” votes and two “no opinion” votes. The ballots were anonymous, but diplomatic and other sources close to the Council told Middle East Eye that the UK, France and China had voted to discourage her. All three are permanent Council members. The result shows both support and resistance, not a settled outcome. The same sources said the US and Russia back Nusseibeh; Israel also supports her but is not on the Council and does not vote. Her totals matched the previous poll on 6 November. A permanent member could formally veto a candidate, but the reported poll votes are not themselves a veto.

01

What did the latest straw poll show about Lana Nusseibeh’s support, and which countries voted to discourage her candidacy?

The informal poll is intended to help determine who will replace Antonio Guterres as UN secretary-general. Nusseibeh’s support matters because the Security Council’s five permanent members can veto a prospective candidate. The poll offers a signal of support, rather than a final appointment decision.

Nusseibeh received seven “encourage” votes, six “discourage” votes and two “no opinion” votes. The ballots were anonymous, but diplomatic and other sources close to the Council told Middle East Eye that the UK, France and China had voted to discourage her. All three are permanent Council members.

The result shows both support and resistance, not a settled outcome. The same sources said the US and Russia back Nusseibeh; Israel also supports her but is not on the Council and does not vote. Her totals matched the previous poll on 6 November. A permanent member could formally veto a candidate, but the reported poll votes are not themselves a veto.

02

How many votes did Nusseibeh receive in each category, and how did her result compare with the previous poll?

The latest informal straw poll gave Lana Nusseibeh seven “encourage” votes, six “discourage” votes and two “no opinion” votes. Together, the categories account for 15 votes. These figures show a mixed response to her candidacy, with the largest group supporting her and nearly as many discouraging her.

The comparison with the previous poll is straightforward: Nusseibeh received exactly the same result in the straw poll held on 6 November. The article does not report a change in support between those two polls. It also notes that ballots are cast anonymously, so the totals show the overall response rather than naming each voter.

The outcome is a snapshot, not a final selection. The article identifies the UK, France and China as the permanent Council members that reportedly voted to discourage her, while the US and Russia were said to back her. Those positions matter because permanent members can veto a prospective candidate. Still, the reported poll totals do not themselves appoint or reject anyone.

03

What is an informal straw poll, and what do “encourage” and “discourage” votes indicate?

The article describes an informal straw poll as a process conducted to help determine who should replace Antonio Guterres as UN secretary-general. Unlike a public, final decision, its votes are anonymous. It gives diplomats an indication of how candidates are being received before the Security Council settles on a nominee.

In this poll, voters could mark “encourage,” “discourage” or “no opinion.” In ordinary use, “encourage” signals that a voter is open to a candidate moving forward, while “discourage” signals that the voter does not support that candidate. “No opinion” records neither position. The article reports these categories but does not provide a detailed official definition of them.

The labels should not be confused with the formal appointment itself. Nusseibeh received seven encouraging votes, six discouraging votes and two no-opinion votes, matching her result on 6 November. The poll is a gauge, and the article says the permanent Security Council members can veto any prospective candidate. A reported discouraging vote, however, is not automatically a formal veto.

04

What could happen to Nusseibeh’s candidacy if a permanent Security Council member opposes it?

The article says that the five permanent members of the Security Council can veto any prospective candidate for UN secretary-general. In established UN procedure, the Council recommends a candidate for appointment by the General Assembly. If a permanent member uses its veto against that recommendation, the candidate cannot be recommended through that decision.

That makes opposition from one of the permanent members consequential. In Nusseibeh’s latest poll, the UK, France and China were reported to have cast “discourage” votes. Those are three of the five permanent members. The article also says the US and Russia backed her, according to the same sources. The poll ballots themselves were anonymous.

The key distinction is between a signal and a formal act. A “discourage” vote in a straw poll indicates opposition, but it does not by itself amount to a veto or settle the selection. Nusseibeh’s totals were unchanged from the poll on 6 November. The article does not say that any permanent member has formally vetoed her candidacy.

05

How does the United Nations choose a new secretary-general after the Security Council’s informal polls?

The article explains that the informal polls help determine who might replace Antonio Guterres, but it does not describe the full selection procedure. Under established UN procedure, the Security Council recommends a candidate for secretary-general, and the General Assembly appoints that person. This means the poll is not the final decision.

In the formal Council stage, a recommendation needs at least nine votes and must not be blocked by a veto from a permanent member. The five permanent members are China, France, Russia, the UK and the US. Informal straw polls can help show which candidates may have support or face opposition before the Council makes its recommendation.

Nusseibeh’s latest poll produced seven “encourage,” six “discourage” and two “no opinion” votes, the same result as on 6 November. The article reports that the UK, France and China discouraged her, while the US and Russia backed her. It does not say what the Council’s final recommendation will be or when it will make one.

06

What does the UN secretary-general do, and why is the job influential?

The article identifies Antonio Guterres as the current UN secretary-general but does not explain the role’s duties. In established UN practice, the secretary-general is the organisation’s chief administrative officer. The role involves managing the UN’s work and carrying out responsibilities set by its member states and governing bodies.

The office is also influential because the secretary-general can act as a public representative and use diplomacy to draw attention to international concerns. The role does not give its holder authority to make every decision for UN members. Much of the organisation’s action depends on its member states and, for security matters, decisions by the Security Council.

The article’s immediate focus is who may replace Guterres. Lana Nusseibeh’s informal poll result was seven “encourage,” six “discourage” and two “no opinion” votes. The article reports that the UK, France and China discouraged her, while the US and Russia backed her. It gives no information about the eventual winner or the secretary-general’s future agenda.

07

Why do the five permanent members of the Security Council have veto power, and how does that power shape UN decisions?

The article says the five permanent Security Council members can veto any prospective secretary-general candidate. The five are China, France, Russia, the UK and the US. The article does not explain the historical reason for giving them this power; in established historical context, the arrangement was part of the UN’s founding structure after the Second World War.

A veto matters because it can prevent the Security Council from adopting a decision, even if other members support it. For choosing a secretary-general, the Council must recommend a candidate before the General Assembly appoints one. A permanent member’s opposition can therefore block a recommendation. An informal “discourage” vote, though, is not itself a formal veto.

The poll illustrates how those positions may shape the process. The UK, France and China were reported to have discouraged Lana Nusseibeh, while the US and Russia were said to back her. Her totals were seven “encourage,” six “discourage” and two “no opinion,” unchanged from the 6 November poll. The article does not report a formal veto.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web