JupiteX Get the app
Social Issues21 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Associating protests with vandalism reduces public support by up to 17%

The brief

The mention of vandalism reduced support for the protests by 17% compared with the control group. That is the effect of adding information about damage, not a finding that every protest involved vandalism. The distinction matters because descriptions can change public opinion even when people are considering the same protests. In the 2022 experiment, participants first read a neutral description of the 2019 and 2021 protests. One group then received information about vandalism, while the control group received no additional information. Participants rated their agreement with the protests on a scale from 1 to 7. The vandalism information caused the largest drop among the single narratives tested. The combined narrative, mentioning both vandalism and the FARC successor party, reduced support by 21%. But adding the party reference to the vandalism narrative did not produce a statistically significant additional drop. The article also notes that organizers can influence vandalism, unlike a group’s reputation. Public reactions to damage therefore matter for how much support a protest retains.

01

By how much did mentioning vandalism reduce support for the protests?

The mention of vandalism reduced support for the protests by 17% compared with the control group. That is the effect of adding information about damage, not a finding that every protest involved vandalism. The distinction matters because descriptions can change public opinion even when people are considering the same protests.

In the 2022 experiment, participants first read a neutral description of the 2019 and 2021 protests. One group then received information about vandalism, while the control group received no additional information. Participants rated their agreement with the protests on a scale from 1 to 7. The vandalism information caused the largest drop among the single narratives tested.

The combined narrative, mentioning both vandalism and the FARC successor party, reduced support by 21%. But adding the party reference to the vandalism narrative did not produce a statistically significant additional drop. The article also notes that organizers can influence vandalism, unlike a group’s reputation. Public reactions to damage therefore matter for how much support a protest retains.

02

How did that drop compare with mentioning the FARC successor party, either alone or alongside vandalism?

The figures show that information about vandalism had a larger effect than a reference to the FARC successor party on its own. The party reference lowered support by about 10%, while vandalism lowered it by 17%. When both appeared together, support fell by 21% compared with the control group.

The experiment randomly assigned 3,020 people to read the same neutral description of the 2019 and 2021 protests, with some groups receiving additional information. The party-only group rated the protests 4.4 out of 7, compared with 4.9 in the control group. The vandalism narrative produced a 17% decline; the combined narrative produced a 21% decline.

Although the combined figure is numerically four percentage points lower than the vandalism-only figure, that difference was not statistically significant. The article concludes that vandalism did most of the damage to support in this experiment. This matters when interpreting claims that connect protests to unpopular groups: the added association may not shift opinion much once damage has already been mentioned.

03

What did “support for the protests” mean in the experiment, and how was it measured?

In this experiment, support for the protests meant respondents’ stated agreement with the protests. It was a measure of opinion, not a count of people who attended, donated, or planned to take action. This distinction matters when interpreting the reported declines: they describe changes in survey ratings.

After reading a neutral description of the 2019 and 2021 protests, each participant rated agreement on a scale from 1 to 7. A control group read only the neutral description. Other groups received added information about the FARC successor party, vandalism, or both. In the control group, the average rating was 4.9; the party-only group averaged 4.4.

The different ratings let the researcher compare reactions to different descriptions of the same protests. The article reports that vandalism lowered support by 17% and the combined narrative by 21%. These results show how added information shifted expressed agreement in this survey. They do not directly measure protest attendance or establish how every person would react outside the experiment.

04

How did randomly giving different groups different descriptions help show that the information changed their support?

Random assignment helped make the comparison fair. Participants were placed by chance into different groups, so, on average, the groups were similar in their characteristics. The main planned difference was the extra information each group read. That matters because different reactions are less likely to reflect pre-existing differences between groups.

Everyone read the same neutral sentence about the 2019 and 2021 protests. Some then read that the FARC successor party had participated, some read that there had been vandalism, and some read both claims. The control group received no added information. All participants rated their agreement with the protests from 1 to 7.

Because the descriptions were assigned at random, the researcher could compare the groups’ ratings and attribute the differences to the information they received, as the article explains. The results showed lower support after the vandalism and party references. They provide evidence that these descriptions can shift opinion in a survey, while not implying that every individual responds in the same way.

05

What can a loss of public support mean for a protest’s growth, media coverage, and ability to put its demands on the agenda?

A decline in public support can matter beyond survey ratings. The article argues that losses of 10% to 21% are substantial in a polarized country where elections are decided by narrow margins. For a protest, public backing can shape its ability to attract attention and keep its demands visible.

The experiment found that mentioning the FARC successor party lowered support by about 10%, while mentioning vandalism lowered it by 17%. Combining the two lowered support by 21%. These results show how descriptions that weaken approval could influence the public environment around a protest, even when people are evaluating the same mobilization.

The article says these drops can help decide whether a protest grows or loses momentum, how the media cover it, and whether its demands enter the public agenda. It also notes that vandalism is something organizers can influence, unlike a group’s reputation. The findings make accurate scrutiny of claims about protests important for citizens and media, especially when a government links a protest to an unpopular group.

06

Why can linking a protest to an unpopular or violent group make people judge the protest more negatively?

Linking a protest to an unpopular or violent group can make people view the protest through that group’s reputation. The article notes that, for most Colombians, the FARC still evokes a negative image. Associating that image with a protest can therefore make the mobilization less appealing to people considering it.

In the experiment, participants who were told that the FARC successor party had participated supported the protests about 10% less than the control group. Vandalism had a bigger effect, reducing support by 17%. The author suggests that when people hear about vandalism, they may blame an actor known for violence, whether or not that actor actually took part.

Together, the two narratives lowered support by 21%, but mentioning the party added no statistically significant effect once vandalism was already in the description. The findings show why claims tying a protest to a group deserve careful scrutiny. In the experiment, mentioning the party was enough to affect ratings; the article notes that no proof was presented to participants.

07

What is political framing, and how can the way an event is described shape what the public thinks about it?

Political framing means presenting an event through particular details or interpretations that guide how people understand it. A protest can be described neutrally, or it can be described alongside vandalism or an unpopular group. Those choices matter because they may influence whether people see protesters as reasonable or identify with them.

The article gives examples from Colombia. In 2021, officials described vandalism as terrorism and connected it to armed groups. In the experiment, respondents read the same neutral description of protests from 2019 and 2021, but some also read that the FARC successor party had participated, that vandalism occurred, or both. Support fell under those added descriptions.

The results indicate that framing can shape public opinion even when the underlying protest description stays the same. Vandalism reduced support by 17%; the combined narrative reduced it by 21%. The author says these narratives can be used by governments on the left or right. For citizens and media, checking claims that link protests to unpopular groups is therefore consequential.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web