JupiteX Get the app
Social Issues21 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Man convicted of arson for deadly Palisades fire in LA

The brief

A federal jury convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht of destroying property by means of fire and arson affecting interstate commerce. The case concerned a small brush fire near a trail in the Santa Monica Mountains National Recreation Area on 1 January 2025. The verdict came in a retrial, after jurors deliberated for three days. Prosecutors said Rinderknecht deliberately started the first blaze. Firefighters quickly suppressed it, but it smouldered underground for days. Nearly a week later, it reignited at the surface. Fierce winds then drove the flames into Pacific Palisades, where the fire killed 12 people and destroyed about 6,800 homes and other structures. Rinderknecht’s defence denied he started the blaze and argued that fireworks caused the New Year’s Day fire. The jury found him guilty under a new indictment that modified the charges from the first trial. He is due to be sentenced on 17 March and could face up to 40 years in prison, prosecutors said.

01

What did the jury convict Jonathan Rinderknecht of, and what fire was he accused of starting?

A federal jury convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht of destroying property by means of fire and arson affecting interstate commerce. The case concerned a small brush fire near a trail in the Santa Monica Mountains National Recreation Area on 1 January 2025. The verdict came in a retrial, after jurors deliberated for three days.

Prosecutors said Rinderknecht deliberately started the first blaze. Firefighters quickly suppressed it, but it smouldered underground for days. Nearly a week later, it reignited at the surface. Fierce winds then drove the flames into Pacific Palisades, where the fire killed 12 people and destroyed about 6,800 homes and other structures.

Rinderknecht’s defence denied he started the blaze and argued that fireworks caused the New Year’s Day fire. The jury found him guilty under a new indictment that modified the charges from the first trial. He is due to be sentenced on 17 March and could face up to 40 years in prison, prosecutors said.

02

Why was there a retrial after the first jury could not reach a unanimous verdict?

A retrial was needed because the first jury could not reach the unanimous verdict required to convict. After deliberations, the 12 jurors were split 10–2 in favour of acquittal. They could not agree unanimously on any of the three original charges, so Judge Anne Hwang declared a mistrial on 26 June.

A mistrial means the case did not end with a verdict on those charges. It did not amount to a conviction or an acquittal. The prosecution chose to bring the case again, but used a new grand jury indictment. That indictment dropped one charge altogether and modified the two remaining counts.

Five months after the first jury deadlocked, a second US District Court jury heard the case. It convicted Rinderknecht of destroying property by means of fire and arson affecting interstate commerce. The verdict came on the third day of deliberations. The retrial therefore produced a conviction where the first trial had ended without a unanimous decision.

03

How many people died, how many structures burned, and how large were the estimated property losses?

The Palisades fire killed 12 people and caused enormous physical and financial damage. Around 6,800 homes and other structures went up in flames. The article estimates property losses at $150 billion (€136 million), making the disaster one of the most destructive wildfires in Los Angeles history.

The fire began as a brush blaze on 1 January 2025. Although firefighters quickly suppressed it smouldered underground for days. It later reignited at the surface, and fierce winds whipped the flames into a conflagration that devastated the seaside enclave of Pacific Palisades. The article links the losses to that later, wind-driven fire.

The Palisades disaster was one of two catastrophic fires that erupted around 7 January. The Eaton fire, about 48 kilometres to the east, killed 19 people and ravaged Altadena. Together, the two fires killed 31 people, according to the figures in the article. Their combined death toll made them the deadliest wildfire incidents ever in Los Angeles County, surpassing the 29 lives lost in 1933’s Griffith Park fire.

04

What evidence did prosecutors cite to connect Rinderknecht to the first fire, and what alternative explanation did the defence offer?

Prosecutors said security camera footage and location data from Rinderknecht’s phone placed him in the vicinity of the 1 January fire when it began. They argued he was the only person there who could reasonably have started it. They also said evidence ruled out other causes. The article does not describe the specific footage or location records in detail.

The first fire started near a trail in the Santa Monica Mountains National Recreation Area. Prosecutors said it was quickly suppressed but smouldered underground before reigniting days later. They also alleged that, during his 911 call, Rinderknecht asked Axiom whether someone could be blamed for lighting a fire because of cigarettes.

The defence offered a different account. Rinderknecht said he witnessed the blaze while watching New Year’s fireworks, called 911, and stayed until firefighters arrived. His lawyer suggested fireworks caused the first fire and that another person set the Palisades inferno later. Rinderknecht denied deliberately starting any fire, but did not testify at either trial.

05

What is a smoldering fire, and how could the first blaze reignite days after firefighters suppressed it?

A smouldering fire burns slowly, often without large flames, and can remain hidden beneath the surface. The article says the New Year’s Day brush fire was quickly suppressed but smouldered underground for days. It does not describe the exact fuel or underground conditions that kept it burning.

As a general fire-science explanation, embers and heat can remain in combustible material such as soil, roots, or buried vegetation after visible flames are gone. If those hot spots later meet oxygen and available fuel, flames can return. This is one way a fire that appears extinguished can reignite; the article does not establish which specific mechanism occurred in this case.

In the Palisades case, the fire reignited at the surface nearly a week later. Fierce winds then drove the flames into a major conflagration. The distinction matters because suppressing visible flames may not always mean every hidden hot spot has gone cold. The source gives the timeline, but not further technical findings about the underground smouldering.

06

How can strong winds and dry brush turn a small fire into a fast-moving, destructive wildfire?

A small fire can become much more destructive when it meets abundant vegetation and strong winds. Dry brush can catch fire readily and provide fuel. Wind can push flames forward, bring fresh air to the fire, and carry burning embers into new areas. These are general fire-science points; the article does not give detailed measurements of fuel dryness or wind speed.

In this case, the article describes a brush fire that firefighters initially suppressed. It smouldered underground for days and then reignited at the surface nearly a week later. Fierce winds whipped the flames into a conflagration. That fire killed 12 people and destroyed around 6,800 homes and other structures in Pacific Palisades.

The scale of the damage shows why a fire’s conditions can matter as much as its initial size. The article identifies the wind as a factor in the fire’s growth, but does not detail the precise spread pattern. It reports estimated property losses of $150 billion (€136 million), underscoring the consequences of a small blaze becoming a major wildfire.

07

What does it mean for arson to affect interstate commerce, and why can that make a fire case a federal crime?

Interstate commerce generally means trade, travel, or other economic activity that crosses state lines or is connected to activity across state lines. Under US federal law, arson can become a federal crime when fire damages property used in, or affecting, interstate or foreign commerce. This is a general explanation of the legal concept, not a detail supplied by the article.

The jury convicted Rinderknecht of arson affecting interstate commerce, as well as destroying property by means of fire. The article identifies the charges but does not say which property or commerce-related facts prosecutors relied on to establish the interstate-commerce element. It also does not explain the legal arguments about that element.

The distinction matters because federal prosecutors need a federal legal basis for a case, rather than relying only on state criminal law. Here, prosecutors tried the case in US District Court, and the jury returned federal arson convictions. Rinderknecht is due to be sentenced on 17 March. A First Assistant US Attorney said he could face up to 40 years in prison.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web