JupiteX Get the app
Social Issues21 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Arizona HOA loses bid to force arbitration over disabled son's golf cart gate

The brief

The appeals court rejected the HOA’s effort to move the LoPrestos’ dispute out of court and into private arbitration. It upheld the trial judge’s refusal to order arbitration, ruling that the association’s rules could not be enforced against the couple because they were one-sided. The decision did not resolve the couple’s underlying claims against the HOA. The HOA relied on arbitration language in two community documents: the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions and the Guidelines for Community Living. The court reviewed both rules. It concluded that neither could be enforced against the LoPrestos, applying Arizona law that requires arbitration agreements to meet basic fairness standards. The September 25, 2026, memorandum decision allows the couple’s lawsuit to proceed in court. The appeals judges also granted them reasonable legal fees and court costs tied to the appeal. The next stage is the continuing dispute over the rejected gate request and the HOA’s handling of it; the ruling did not decide who will ultimately prevail on those claims.

01

What did the Arizona Court of Appeals decide about the HOA’s effort to force the LoPrestos into arbitration?

The appeals court rejected the HOA’s effort to move the LoPrestos’ dispute out of court and into private arbitration. It upheld the trial judge’s refusal to order arbitration, ruling that the association’s rules could not be enforced against the couple because they were one-sided. The decision did not resolve the couple’s underlying claims against the HOA.

The HOA relied on arbitration language in two community documents: the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions and the Guidelines for Community Living. The court reviewed both rules. It concluded that neither could be enforced against the LoPrestos, applying Arizona law that requires arbitration agreements to meet basic fairness standards.

The September 25, 2026, memorandum decision allows the couple’s lawsuit to proceed in court. The appeals judges also granted them reasonable legal fees and court costs tied to the appeal. The next stage is the continuing dispute over the rejected gate request and the HOA’s handling of it; the ruling did not decide who will ultimately prevail on those claims.

02

What can the LoPrestos do now that the court refused to order arbitration?

The practical result is that the LoPrestos are not required to take their dispute to private arbitration under the rules cited by the HOA. Their lawsuit can move forward in the regular court system. This matters because the couple’s claims against the association have not yet been decided; the appeal concerned where the disagreement should be heard, not whether the HOA was at fault.

Kevin and Jennifer LoPresto sued after the association rejected their request to replace a single backyard gate with a wider double gate. They accused the HOA of breaking its contract duties and failing to handle homeowner requests fairly. The association sought to have those claims resolved through arbitration, but the courts rejected that effort because its rules were one-sided and unenforceable against the couple.

The appeals ruling leaves the underlying case to continue in court. The judges also granted the LoPrestos reasonable legal fees and court costs connected to the appeal. The decision does not say how the lawsuit will end, or whether the association will ultimately be required to approve the gate change.

03

Why did the court find the HOA’s main arbitration rule unfair to homeowners?

The appeals court found the arbitration rule in the community’s main declaration one-sided. The article explains that a rule can be substantively unconscionable when it places strict requirements on one side without imposing similar duties on the other. In this dispute, the court concluded the HOA’s arbitration rules were unfair and could not be enforced against the LoPrestos.

The association relied on subsection 12.8.2 of the declaration, as well as a separate community-living guideline. The article states that people covered by the declaration had to take their claims through arbitration. The court examined the two documents and rejected both as a basis to compel the couple to arbitrate. The supplied account does not give the complete wording of the subsection.

The ruling applies the fairness standard described in an earlier Arizona case, Stevens/Leinweber/Sullens, Inc. v. Holm Development and Management, Inc. Arizona law generally supports written arbitration agreements, but the court said basic fairness still matters. The result is that the LoPrestos can pursue their lawsuit in court; it does not settle their underlying claims against the HOA.

04

What is arbitration, and how is it different from resolving a dispute in court?

Arbitration is a process for settling a disagreement outside the regular court system. An independent person or panel hears the dispute. The article notes that people often use arbitration to resolve contract fights without holding a full court trial. It can therefore offer a different route from a lawsuit heard in court.

In the LoPrestos’ case, the HOA argued that community rules required the couple to use arbitration instead of continuing their lawsuit in court. The association cited its Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions and its Guidelines for Community Living. The trial judge refused to order arbitration, and the appeals court upheld that refusal after finding the rules one-sided and unenforceable against the couple.

The distinction mattered because the HOA was asking to change the forum for the dispute, not simply to resolve the gate request. The appeals ruling allows the lawsuit to proceed in court, but it does not decide the underlying claims. The article says arbitration is often used for contract disputes; it does not describe every procedural difference between arbitration and a court case.

05

How many separate community documents did the HOA cite as requiring arbitration?

The association relied on two documents when it argued that the LoPrestos had to settle their complaints through private arbitration. One was the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions, the neighborhood’s main set of property rules. The other was the Wigwam Creek South Community Association Guidelines for Community Living.

The HOA asked the Superior Court to send the lawsuit to arbitration based on those documents. The trial judge refused, and the association appealed. The appeals court examined both sets of rules and concluded that neither could be enforced against the couple because the arbitration provisions were one-sided.

The number of documents is important, but the court’s decision focused on whether their arbitration rules met basic fairness standards. Arizona law generally supports written arbitration agreements, yet an unfair rule may not be enforceable. The ruling means the LoPrestos’ lawsuit can continue in court. It does not decide the dispute over the gate or the couple’s other claims against the association.

06

What change to their property did the LoPrestos request, and why?

The couple asked to replace a single gate with a wider double gate at their home in Wigwam Creek South, Arizona. They explained that the larger opening was needed so their disabled son could park his golf cart in the backyard. Their request concerned a change to the property, which is subject to the planned neighborhood’s rules.

Kevin and Jennifer LoPresto submitted a formal application in November 2024. The Wigwam Creek South Community Association rejected it. The couple challenged the decision, but the HOA maintained its refusal after reviewing their complaint. They later sued, accusing the association of breaking its contract duties and failing to act fairly when handling homeowners’ requests.

The gate request is the background to the lawsuit, but the appeals decision dealt with the HOA’s attempt to require private arbitration. The court found the association’s arbitration rules one-sided and refused to compel arbitration. As a result, the couple can continue their case in court. The ruling does not say whether the HOA must approve the double gate.

07

Why can a court reject a written arbitration agreement even when arbitration is generally supported by law?

Support for arbitration does not make every written arbitration rule enforceable. The appeals court noted that Arizona law generally favors written arbitration agreements as a way to settle disputes quickly and for less money. But an agreement must also meet basic fairness standards. If it places strict requirements on one side without similar duties on the other, it can be legally unfair.

The court applied that principle to the HOA’s community rules. The association relied on arbitration provisions in its declaration and its Guidelines for Community Living to try to move the LoPrestos’ lawsuit out of court. The appeals judges found the rules one-sided and ruled that neither could be enforced against the couple. The article connects this reasoning to an earlier Arizona case on substantively unconscionable arbitration rules.

Because the rules failed that fairness test, the HOA could not force the LoPrestos into private arbitration under those documents. Their lawsuit can proceed in court, and the couple received reasonable fees and costs tied to the appeal. The ruling addresses enforceability, not the ultimate outcome of the gate dispute or the couple’s other claims.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web