Women in high offices does not mean equality has been achieved: Supreme Court judge BV Nagarathna
Justice Nagarathna means that seeing a small number of women in prominent roles does not reveal the opportunities available to women generally. Their presence is not proof that women across India can access education, employment, or professional advancement. Equality must be judged across society, not by a few exceptional careers. She said women’s experiences differ, and that some women struggle to pursue education or careers even when they are well qualified. She also called for introspection about social assumptions and institutional practices that can limit women. The issue is not simply whether a woman may enter a profession, but whether she can advance and hold authority. The article describes a continuing gender imbalance in the higher judiciary: women are three of the Supreme Court’s 37 sitting judges and 111 of 781 high court judges. Nagarathna said women’s representation should extend to government legal panels and leadership. Her point is that visible achievement matters, but it cannot replace wider access and opportunity.
What does Justice Nagarathna mean when she says that a few women in high offices do not prove equality has been achieved?
Justice Nagarathna means that seeing a small number of women in prominent roles does not reveal the opportunities available to women generally. Their presence is not proof that women across India can access education, employment, or professional advancement. Equality must be judged across society, not by a few exceptional careers.
She said women’s experiences differ, and that some women struggle to pursue education or careers even when they are well qualified. She also called for introspection about social assumptions and institutional practices that can limit women. The issue is not simply whether a woman may enter a profession, but whether she can advance and hold authority.
The article describes a continuing gender imbalance in the higher judiciary: women are three of the Supreme Court’s 37 sitting judges and 111 of 781 high court judges. Nagarathna said women’s representation should extend to government legal panels and leadership. Her point is that visible achievement matters, but it cannot replace wider access and opportunity.
How many women judges are there in India’s Supreme Court and high courts, according to the figures in the article?
The figures in the article show that women remain a small share of India’s higher judiciary. The Supreme Court has three women judges among its 37 sitting judges. Across the country’s 25 high courts, 111 of the 781 sitting judges are women. That amounts to around 14% of high court judges.
These numbers describe women’s representation in the judiciary, not the total number of women lawyers or legal professionals. They help explain why Justice Nagarathna emphasized opportunities beyond simply entering the legal profession. Her call for one-third representation on government legal panels also addresses access to professional roles and institutional authority.
The figures point to a gap between the constitutional promise of equality and women’s current presence in senior legal institutions. The article does not provide a target or timetable for changing the judicial numbers. It notes that Nagarathna is expected to become India’s first woman Chief Justice in September 2027, though her time in the role will be brief.
What barriers does the article say can limit women’s access to education, careers, safety, and professional advancement?
The article describes structural barriers that can restrict women’s access to education, employment, and professional opportunities. Justice Nagarathna said many women find it difficult to pursue education or a career, even when well qualified. She urged Indian society, particularly men, to reflect on this problem. The article links discrimination to social assumptions and institutional practices.
For professional advancement, Nagarathna stressed that entering a profession is not enough. Women also need opportunities to represent the State, advise public institutions, and exercise legal authority. The article cites the Supreme Court’s Vishaka guidelines against workplace sexual harassment as an example of action addressing safety at work. It does not provide a detailed account of other safety barriers or specific employment barriers.
Her proposal for one-third representation for women lawyers on government panels, including panels for public sector undertakings and legal aid, addresses some institutional opportunities. The judicial figures show the wider imbalance: women are around 14% of high court judges. The article argues that access must include advancement and leadership, not just entry.
What is substantive equality, and how is it different from treating everyone equally under the law?
Substantive equality focuses on whether people can actually enjoy equal rights and opportunities in real life. Formal equality generally means applying the same legal rule to everyone. But identical treatment may not remove obstacles that affect some groups more than others. The article describes this wider approach as moving beyond formal equality to confront discrimination rooted in social assumptions and institutional practices.
For example, a woman may have the formal right to enter a profession but still face limited chances to represent the State, advise public institutions, or take part in legal authority. Nagarathna said equality in the administration of justice must include those opportunities for advancement. She also emphasized that women’s experiences are diverse and should not be represented by only a few prominent figures.
This distinction matters because the article says many qualified women struggle to pursue education or careers. Nagarathna called for one-third representation for women lawyers on government panels, including legal aid panels and those serving public sector undertakings. That proposal addresses participation beyond a legal right to enter the profession.
What opportunities could one-third representation for women on government legal panels open up?
One-third representation for women lawyers on government legal panels could widen access to important professional roles. Nagarathna included panels representing public sector undertakings and those providing legal aid in her proposal. The aim is not only to increase women’s presence, but to open routes to work that carries responsibility and influence.
She explained the mechanism as participation in the administration of justice beyond the right to enter the legal profession. Women should have opportunities to represent the State, advise public institutions, and participate in the exercise of legal authority. These roles can give women lawyers professional experience and a place in institutional decision-making. The article does not specify how the proposed share would be implemented.
The proposal comes amid a persistent gender imbalance in the higher judiciary: women are 111 of 781 sitting high court judges, around 14%, and three of 37 Supreme Court judges. Nagarathna’s argument is that equal participation requires advancement as well as entry. Government panels are one area where institutions could create more opportunities for women lawyers.
How have court rulings and laws addressed discrimination against women in areas such as inheritance, workplace safety, and employment?
The lecture traced women’s rights from the colonial legal order to the Constitution’s promise of equality. Nagarathna said legislative reforms and court rulings have gradually expanded that promise. The article describes the shift as moving beyond formal equality to address discrimination embedded in social assumptions and institutional practices.
The article gives two concrete examples. In 2005, the Supreme Court recognized daughters as equal coparceners in ancestral property. It also issued the Vishaka guidelines against workplace sexual harassment. These examples concern inheritance rights and protection from sexual harassment at work. The supplied text begins to mention rulings challenging gender-based restrictions, but ends before naming or explaining those rulings.
These legal developments matter, but the article presents the journey as unfinished. Nagarathna says many qualified women still face difficulty pursuing education or careers. She also calls for women’s representation in government legal panels, arguing that participation in the profession must include opportunities for advancement and institutional leadership. The article does not give details of particular employment rulings beyond these points.
What do Articles 14 and 21 of the Indian Constitution protect, and how do they support women’s equality?
Article 14 of the Indian Constitution protects equality before the law and equal protection of the laws. Article 21 protects life and personal liberty. These are well-established descriptions of the constitutional provisions; the article itself refers to the constitutional promise of equality under Articles 14 and 21 without explaining their full legal wording.
Nagarathna said that this promise has expanded through laws and court rulings. The article gives the example of the Supreme Court’s 2005 recognition of daughters as equal coparceners in ancestral property, as well as the Vishaka guidelines against workplace sexual harassment. Such developments show how courts and legislation have applied equality to particular areas of women’s lives.
The article says the legal journey is unfinished because discrimination can remain rooted in social assumptions and institutional practices. Nagarathna called for substantive equality that reflects women’s varied experiences and wider access to education, careers, and professional advancement. Her call for women lawyers to hold one-third of government legal-panel representation is one proposed step toward more equal participation.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web