Cop31: Talks deadlocked as EU signals willingness to walk away if no move on fossil fuels
The fight is over whether COP31’s final agreement will name fossil fuels as the cause of climate change. The EU and other countries want that acknowledgement included, while oil-producing countries want references to fossil fuels omitted. The wording matters because it would show whether countries are still committed to acting on the main cause identified in the talks. The EU also wants the agreement to restate the 2023 COP28 commitment to transition away from fossil fuels. The article says there has been little progress on that pledge, and COP31 was presented as a chance to get countries moving. The second draft, issued on Thursday, proposed omitting any reference to it. The EU sees that omission as a backward step and says weak wording would be unacceptable amid worsening climate change. Several EU countries have also rejected a possible compromise that would leave out fossil fuel wording while deleting support for carbon capture and storage. The final wording remained unsettled as the summit ran overtime.
What wording about fossil fuels is dividing COP31, and what 2023 COP28 commitment does the EU want reaffirmed?
The fight is over whether COP31’s final agreement will name fossil fuels as the cause of climate change. The EU and other countries want that acknowledgement included, while oil-producing countries want references to fossil fuels omitted. The wording matters because it would show whether countries are still committed to acting on the main cause identified in the talks.
The EU also wants the agreement to restate the 2023 COP28 commitment to transition away from fossil fuels. The article says there has been little progress on that pledge, and COP31 was presented as a chance to get countries moving. The second draft, issued on Thursday, proposed omitting any reference to it.
The EU sees that omission as a backward step and says weak wording would be unacceptable amid worsening climate change. Several EU countries have also rejected a possible compromise that would leave out fossil fuel wording while deleting support for carbon capture and storage. The final wording remained unsettled as the summit ran overtime.
What would happen if COP31 ends without a final agreement?
Without a final agreement at COP31, the issues being negotiated would not be settled at this summit. The article says they would all be pushed to COP32, so the dispute over fossil fuel wording and other parts of the cover decision would remain unresolved for now.
The talks were already in overtime: the summit was scheduled to end on Friday evening, but a third draft had still not appeared by lunchtime on Saturday. One possible compromise would have omitted fossil fuel wording and removed controversial support for carbon capture and storage. But several EU countries opposed that approach, and Panama said it would block a final text that did not mention fossil fuels.
The next stated venue for the unresolved work is Ethiopia, which is to host COP32 next year. The article does not describe any other immediate consequence of failing to agree. The outcome therefore depends on whether countries can reach a text that no nation actively blocks before the summit ends.
Why is the EU consulting small island states and least-developed countries before deciding whether to block a deal?
The EU is consulting small island developing states, or Sids, and least developed countries, or LDCs, before deciding whether to make fossil fuel wording a red line. The article says the EU wants to understand their views before taking a position that could prevent a final agreement.
Those groups have ties with oil-producing countries, which want references to fossil fuels left out. The EU also does not want to block a cover decision if poor nations believe they would be made more vulnerable without some form of agreement. That concern makes the decision more than a dispute over the precise wording.
The EU is therefore weighing its demand for a clear acknowledgement of fossil fuels against the views and interests of poorer countries. It is not yet clear from the article whether the EU will ultimately block a text without the wording. Panama, separately, has said it will firmly block any proposed final text that does not refer to fossil fuels.
How does consensus work at a COP summit, and how can a text pass without every country actively supporting it?
At a COP summit, agreements must be reached by consensus. In practical terms, the article says a text can still pass even when some countries do not signal support, provided no single country actively objects. So consensus does not require every country to express enthusiastic approval.
That distinction matters in the COP31 deadlock. The EU and other countries want fossil fuels acknowledged, while oil-producing countries want references omitted. Panama has said it will firmly block any proposed final text without a fossil fuel reference. A clear objection from a country can therefore prevent the text from passing, even if other countries are ready to accept it.
The article does not give a detailed account of the summit’s procedures beyond this rule. But it shows why a country’s active objection matters more than a lack of affirmative support. If no final agreement is reached, the article says all issues will be pushed to COP32, hosted by Ethiopia next year.
What is carbon capture and storage, and why do some oil-producing countries promote it?
Carbon capture and storage, or CCS, is described in the article as technology intended to suck emissions back out of the atmosphere and store them indefinitely. The article calls it unproven. Its role in the COP31 dispute is important because wording on CCS appeared in a possible compromise over the final agreement.
Oil-producing countries promote CCS, claiming it could reduce the need to eradicate fossil fuels. A rough draft in circulation on Saturday suggested leaving fossil fuel wording out while also deleting controversial wording backing CCS. This would remove two disputed elements from the text, rather than explicitly naming fossil fuels and reaffirming the transition pledge.
Several EU countries, including France, Spain, the Netherlands and Ireland, strongly rejected that suggestion. They argued they could not leave Turkey with an agreement that fudged why there is a climate crisis. The article does not detail how CCS works or assess its performance beyond calling it unproven and describing the claims made by its promoters.
How much of the world's energy still comes from fossil fuels?
The article does not state how much of the world’s energy still comes from fossil fuels. Its focus is the COP31 dispute over whether the final agreement should refer to fossil fuels and reaffirm a commitment to transition away from them.
For context from outside the article, widely used recent global energy estimates put coal, oil and gas together at roughly four-fifths of primary energy use. This is an approximate share, not a figure supplied by the source text. Estimates vary with the year, data source and whether energy is measured as primary energy or by another measure.
That scale helps explain why the wording is consequential: fossil fuels remain a major part of the global energy system, while countries are negotiating how to describe moving away from them. The article reports little progress on the 2023 COP28 pledge and says COP31 was presented as a chance to get countries moving. It does not provide a more precise global energy breakdown.
How does burning coal, oil, and gas warm the planet?
The article says the EU and other countries want the COP31 agreement to acknowledge fossil fuels as the cause of climate change. It does not explain the scientific process by which burning coal, oil and gas raises temperatures, so the explanation here draws on established climate science.
When these fuels are burned, they release carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas. Greenhouse gases absorb and re-emit some of the heat Earth sends toward space. This slows the loss of heat to space and raises the planet’s average temperature. Burning fossil fuels is a major source of human-caused carbon dioxide emissions.
That mechanism helps explain why the wording matters to negotiators: the EU argues that an agreement should not leave out what it sees as the cause of the climate crisis. The article says little progress has been made on the 2023 commitment to transition away from fossil fuels. It does not quantify emissions or describe other causes of climate change.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web