Chasing hot themes, hypergrowth stocks or multibaggers? Why Rajeev Thakkar of PPFAS Mutual Fund prefers fundamentals
Thakkar says PPFAS bases investment choices on a company’s business quality, financial performance and valuation. It does not chase popular themes or buy shares simply because investors hope they could become multibaggers. The distinction matters because a promising business can still be a poor investment if its share price already assumes too much future growth. He illustrated this by comparing Coal India with an unnamed company in a popular investment theme. Coal India had revenue of Rs 1.71 lakh crore and profits above Rs 33,000 crore. It offered a 6.6% dividend yield and traded at a P/E of around 7. The other company had lower revenue and profits, paid no dividends and traded at a P/E above 700. Thakkar acknowledged that the other company could grow. His question was how long it might take to reach the profit level of a business already earning over Rs 33,000 crore. PPFAS’s approach weighs that growth possibility against the current price, rather than treating a hot theme as a reason to invest.
What does Rajeev Thakkar say guides PPFAS’s investment choices instead of chasing popular themes or potential multibaggers?
Thakkar says PPFAS bases investment choices on a company’s business quality, financial performance and valuation. It does not chase popular themes or buy shares simply because investors hope they could become multibaggers. The distinction matters because a promising business can still be a poor investment if its share price already assumes too much future growth.
He illustrated this by comparing Coal India with an unnamed company in a popular investment theme. Coal India had revenue of Rs 1.71 lakh crore and profits above Rs 33,000 crore. It offered a 6.6% dividend yield and traded at a P/E of around 7. The other company had lower revenue and profits, paid no dividends and traded at a P/E above 700.
Thakkar acknowledged that the other company could grow. His question was how long it might take to reach the profit level of a business already earning over Rs 33,000 crore. PPFAS’s approach weighs that growth possibility against the current price, rather than treating a hot theme as a reason to invest.
How did Coal India and the hot-theme company compare in revenue, profits, dividend yield and P/E ratio?
The comparison highlights how differently the two companies were valued and how much profit each generated. Coal India reported revenue of Rs 1.71 lakh crore and profits of more than Rs 33,000 crore. The unnamed company operating in a popular investment theme had revenue of Rs 78,000 crore and profits below Rs 500 crore.
Coal India offered a 6.6% dividend yield and traded at a price-to-earnings, or P/E, ratio of around 7. The other company paid no dividends and traded at a P/E above 700. These figures show the contrast Thakkar wanted to illustrate: investors paid a far higher multiple of current earnings for the hot-theme company, despite its much smaller reported profits.
Thakkar stressed that the comparison was not meant to criticise the other company. He accepted that it could grow its business and profits. His point was that investors should consider how long that growth might take to close the profit gap, and whether the price already assumes a great deal of future success.
What is a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio, and what does a very high P/E suggest investors expect from a company?
A price-to-earnings, or P/E, ratio compares a company’s share price with its earnings per share. In simple terms, it shows how much investors are paying for each unit of current earnings. It is one way to describe a stock’s valuation, though it does not by itself explain whether the price is justified.
A very high P/E can suggest that investors expect earnings to rise significantly in the future. Thakkar’s example was a company in a popular investment theme with a P/E above 700, while it earned less than Rs 500 crore. By comparison, Coal India earned over Rs 33,000 crore and traded at a P/E of around 7. The contrast illustrates the different prices investors were paying relative to profits.
A high multiple is not proof that a company will fail, nor does a low one guarantee success. Thakkar acknowledged that the hot-theme company might grow. His broader point was to test whether expected growth can justify the price, and how long it could take to deliver the profit levels investors appear to anticipate.
How can a company’s profits triple while its share price falls?
A company’s profits can grow while its stock falls if investors had already paid a high price based on expectations of even stronger future growth. When those expectations are not met, the share price can decline despite better business results. The lesson is that returns depend not only on company performance, but also on the valuation investors pay at the outset.
Thakkar cited a company whose profits tripled over five years while its stock price fell by around one-third. He explained that the starting valuation was too high and investors had built substantial future growth into the price. Even after the correction and the threefold increase in profits, the stock still traded at a P/E of more than 70.
The example does not mean that profit growth is unimportant. It shows that growth alone may not make a share a good investment if the purchase price is excessive. Investors still need to compare the company’s prospects with the expectations already reflected in its valuation. A promising, well-managed business can disappoint shareholders when its price leaves little room for error.
Why might a company with no earnings growth still appeal to investors if it costs five times its earnings and pays all its profits as dividends?
Thakkar challenged the idea that investors must always prefer companies with high earnings growth. A business with no growth could still appeal if it turns its earnings into cash flow and distributes all its profits to shareholders. In that case, investors receive cash from the business rather than relying only on future earnings increases or a higher share price.
His example was theoretical: a stock trading at five times earnings and paying out all its profits as dividends would offer a 20% dividend yield. The mechanism is the relationship between the price paid and the cash distributed. If earnings stay unchanged, the dividend stream can still provide a return relative to the purchase price, assuming the company continues paying it.
Thakkar said he would be comfortable owning such a business even if earnings did not grow for 25 years. This is not a prediction about any specific company or a guarantee of future payouts. It illustrates why investors should examine cash generation, dividend distribution and valuation alongside growth rates and earnings multiples.
How could heavy AI spending or the spread of open-source models affect companies whose success depends on a single AI business?
Thakkar described AI as a significant technological development with the potential to create substantial opportunities. But he also cautioned that excessive capital expenditure in the sector could lead to disruption over the next two to three years. For companies whose success depends heavily on one AI model or emerging business, that makes the sustainability of the business especially important to consider.
He also pointed to open-source and open-weight AI models. They may not match the most advanced frontier models in every respect, but could be sufficient for several everyday business applications. If such models meet users’ needs, companies relying on a single model may face a different competitive landscape. The article does not specify which firms would be affected or how large any impact could be.
PPFAS sees businesses with multiple established revenue streams as having a different risk profile from those dependent largely on one AI model or emerging business. Thakkar’s comments identify possible sources of disruption, not a certain outcome. The fund house’s framing is to consider both the opportunity AI presents and the concentration of a company’s revenue and business success.
How do a business’s earnings, cash flows, growth prospects and purchase price combine to shape an investor’s return?
Earnings indicate a company’s reported profits, while cash flows show the cash it generates. Growth prospects matter because they can change future profits and cash generation. But an investor’s result also depends on the purchase price: the more optimistic expectations already built into a share price, the harder it may be for future performance to justify that price.
Thakkar’s examples show these factors working together. Coal India had profits above Rs 33,000 crore, a 6.6% dividend yield and a P/E around 7, while the hot-theme company earned less than Rs 500 crore and had a P/E above 700. Separately, a company tripled profits in five years, yet its share price fell by about one-third because the starting valuation was too high.
He also described a zero-growth business that could still appeal if its cash flows matched earnings and it paid all profits as dividends. At five times earnings, that theoretical stock would yield 20%. Together, the examples show why investors must weigh earnings, cash returns, future growth and valuation rather than relying on one measure.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web