Administration tries to intervene after Kalshi is threatened with restraining order
The Trump administration wanted federal Judge Lorna Schofield to prevent New York Judge Melissa Crane from ruling on the state attorney general’s request for a temporary restraining order against Kalshi. The request mattered because Kalshi argued that such an order could disrupt its business nationwide, not just in New York. At an emergency telephone hearing Friday, an attorney for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which regulates Kalshi, argued that the order could completely shut down Kalshi’s operations nationwide. New York attorney Kate Rhodes Janofsky responded that a state-court hearing was already set for Monday and that Kalshi had not shown evidence of irreparable harm or market disruption. Schofield denied the administration’s request, saying the application was denied. That left the TRO request for Crane to consider in state court. Her decision did not decide whether New York’s claims against Kalshi were correct; the scheduled state hearing was the next step.
What did the Trump administration ask federal Judge Schofield to do, and how did she rule?
The Trump administration wanted federal Judge Lorna Schofield to prevent New York Judge Melissa Crane from ruling on the state attorney general’s request for a temporary restraining order against Kalshi. The request mattered because Kalshi argued that such an order could disrupt its business nationwide, not just in New York.
At an emergency telephone hearing Friday, an attorney for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which regulates Kalshi, argued that the order could completely shut down Kalshi’s operations nationwide. New York attorney Kate Rhodes Janofsky responded that a state-court hearing was already set for Monday and that Kalshi had not shown evidence of irreparable harm or market disruption.
Schofield denied the administration’s request, saying the application was denied. That left the TRO request for Crane to consider in state court. Her decision did not decide whether New York’s claims against Kalshi were correct; the scheduled state hearing was the next step.
What is a temporary restraining order, and what can it temporarily stop a business from doing?
A temporary restraining order, or TRO, is a short-term court order that can require a person or business to stop a particular action while a legal dispute is considered. It is not, by itself, a final decision on the lawsuit. The article reports that New York asked for a TRO against Kalshi, but it does not explain the general legal test or duration for such an order.
Here, Attorney General Letitia James asked state Judge Melissa Crane to stop Kalshi from offering sports contracts without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission. So the specific business activity the requested order could temporarily halt was the offering of those contracts in the circumstances New York challenged.
Crane set a hearing for Monday; the article does not say that she had granted the order. Kalshi warned that a TRO could have wider consequences, including forcing the liquidation of open positions. The request’s scope and any resulting restrictions depended on the state judge’s decision, which remained pending in the reported events.
Why does New York's attorney general say Kalshi's sports contracts break state law?
New York Attorney General Letitia James argues that Kalshi’s sports contracts cross lines set by state gambling laws. Her lawsuit, filed in July, claims the platform violates New York rules that prohibit wagering on games involving New York college teams and prohibit sports betting for people under 21. Those are the legal grounds the article identifies for the state’s challenge.
The immediate request is narrower: James asked Judge Melissa Crane to stop Kalshi from offering sports contracts without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission. The state is therefore seeking to halt the challenged offering while its lawsuit proceeds, rather than asking for a general ruling about every prediction market.
The lawsuit does not seek to shut Kalshi down, according to the article. If James succeeds, however, Kalshi could have to change how it operates. The state judge set a hearing on the requested restraining order for Monday, while Kalshi warned that the order could affect its operations far beyond New York.
How broad did Kalshi say the TRO's effects could be, and what did it warn might happen to open positions?
Kalshi described the potential effects of New York’s requested temporary restraining order as much broader than the state itself. Its attorney, Sean Murphy, told Judge Melissa Crane that the order would likely force the liquidation of all open positions and disrupt markets far beyond New York. The administration’s argument in federal court similarly characterized the risk as a nationwide shutdown.
The key mechanism in Kalshi’s warning was liquidation: open positions would have to be closed or otherwise resolved, rather than remaining active. Kalshi’s regulator’s attorney, Andrew Weisberg, said the order would completely shut down Kalshi’s operations nationwide and disrupt one of the regulator’s markets. These were arguments about what might happen, not findings made by either judge.
Judge Crane scheduled a hearing for Monday, and the article does not report a ruling on the TRO. Federal Judge Lorna Schofield declined to block that state-court hearing. The actual reach of any order, and whether it would affect all open positions, therefore remained unresolved in the reported events.
If Kalshi had to liquidate open positions, what would that mean for its customers and markets?
Liquidating open positions means closing positions that are still active. For Kalshi customers, that would mean their existing contracts could not simply remain open under the same terms; the article does not explain the precise settlement process or say what any customer would receive. It is important not to treat Kalshi’s warning as a confirmed outcome.
Kalshi attorney Sean Murphy told Judge Melissa Crane that a TRO would likely force liquidation of all open positions. He warned that this could disrupt markets far beyond New York. Kalshi’s regulator’s attorney also argued that the restraining order could completely disrupt one of its regulated markets and shut down Kalshi’s operations nationwide.
Those statements described the harm Kalshi and its regulator feared if the order were granted. The article reports that Judge Crane set a hearing for Monday, but it does not report her decision or any actual liquidation. Federal Judge Lorna Schofield declined to stop the state judge from considering the request, so the effect on customers and markets depended on what the state court decided.
Why did the federal judge leave the TRO request to the state court, and what does that show about state and federal court authority?
Federal Judge Lorna Schofield declined to step in because, as New York’s attorney argued, a state-court hearing on the restraining-order request was already scheduled for Monday. New York also said Kalshi had not provided evidence of irreparable harm or market disruption. Schofield agreed to deny the requested federal intervention.
The dispute arose after U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick rejected Kalshi’s attempt to move James’s lawsuit from New York state court to federal court. Broderick ruled that prediction markets do not necessarily fall outside state jurisdiction. Schofield’s separate decision meant she would not prevent state Judge Melissa Crane from considering James’s TRO request.
This shows a limit in what happened here: the federal judge did not block the state court from proceeding, and the state judge’s hearing remained scheduled. It does not establish a broad rule that state courts always control prediction-market disputes. Crane still had to consider the request, and the article does not report her eventual ruling.
Why can prediction markets like Kalshi face both state gambling laws and federal derivatives oversight?
Prediction markets can raise both federal and state questions because the same activity may involve financial contracts and wagers on sports. The article identifies the Commodity Futures Trading Commission as Kalshi’s regulator, while New York’s attorney general claims the platform’s sports contracts violate state laws. It also reports that a federal judge ruled prediction markets do not necessarily fall outside state jurisdiction.
In this case, the CFTC’s attorney argued that New York’s requested order could disrupt a federally regulated market. New York, in turn, asked its state court to stop Kalshi from offering sports contracts without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission. The article does not explain the legal boundaries between derivatives oversight and state gambling laws; those boundaries are part of the dispute.
The immediate issue was whether the state judge should consider a TRO, not a final resolution of every question about oversight. Federal Judge Schofield declined to intervene, and Judge Crane had a hearing set for Monday. The article leaves open how the courts will resolve the competing claims.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web