Honor Killings and Blood Feuds Remain Widespread in North Caucasus
Honor killings are murders of women accused of violating social norms. Blood feuds are cycles in which families attack one another over a generation or more. The article describes both as crimes that Soviet authorities tried to eliminate as “survivals of the past.” They differ in their immediate framing: an honor killing is linked to a woman’s alleged breach of social rules, while a blood feud involves continuing attacks between families. The article notes that some traditional local leaders accepted or promoted both forms of violence as ways to impose control amid social breakdown. The practices remain a major concern across the North Caucasus, especially in its eastern third: Chechnya, Ingushetia, and Dagestan. Exact totals are hard to establish because data are lacking. The article says the available evidence points to deeply rooted problems, and that reducing them will require enormous, long-term effort. Reporting by threatened people, relatives, and regional experts has helped bring more evidence to light.
What are honor killings and blood feuds?
Honor killings are murders of women accused of violating social norms. Blood feuds are cycles in which families attack one another over a generation or more. The article describes both as crimes that Soviet authorities tried to eliminate as “survivals of the past.”
They differ in their immediate framing: an honor killing is linked to a woman’s alleged breach of social rules, while a blood feud involves continuing attacks between families. The article notes that some traditional local leaders accepted or promoted both forms of violence as ways to impose control amid social breakdown.
The practices remain a major concern across the North Caucasus, especially in its eastern third: Chechnya, Ingushetia, and Dagestan. Exact totals are hard to establish because data are lacking. The article says the available evidence points to deeply rooted problems, and that reducing them will require enormous, long-term effort. Reporting by threatened people, relatives, and regional experts has helped bring more evidence to light.
How widespread are these killings in the North Caucasus, and why is it difficult to know the exact numbers?
The article describes honor killings and blood feuds as major, continuing problems in the North Caucasus. It says they likely increased after the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, despite local officials’ claims that they were countering the trend. The region’s eastern third—Chechnya, Ingushetia, and Dagestan—is identified as especially affected.
But the article gives no dependable total or rate. Its stated reason is a lack of data, which makes it difficult to say exactly how much the crimes have increased. For years, accounts from the region were often dismissed as anecdotal and overshadowed by military conflicts and officials’ claims of success.
A discussion sparked by Dagestani law professor Durey Ziyadova’s proposal brought more evidence into public view. Reporting by people who faced threats, relatives describing what happened to family members, and regional experts also helped. The evidence points to a deep-rooted problem, but it does not supply a precise count. The article says serious reductions will require long-term effort.
Why did honor killings and blood feuds become more common after the Soviet Union collapsed?
The article links the post-Soviet rise in honor killings and blood feuds to weakened state attention and capacity. After the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, Moscow paid little attention, while regional governments lacked the capacity and, in some cases, the interest to address the crimes. The article says cases rose rapidly, though it does not provide exact totals.
The two post-Soviet Chechen wars further weakened police powers. People fleeing the conflict moved into neighboring republics, and traditional local Islamic and ethnic leaders gained influence. Some of those leaders accepted or promoted honor killings and blood feuds as a way to impose some control on societies close to disintegration.
These changes helped violence persist, while official claims of success were questioned by observers. Reports of horrific cases were often treated as anecdotal or overshadowed by military conflict. The article says the problem is deeply rooted, especially in Chechnya, Ingushetia, and Dagestan. It argues that reducing the crimes will take enormous, sustained effort, rather than a quick fix.
How did war and weakened policing affect violence in the region?
The article says the two post-Soviet Chechen wars further increased honor killings and blood feuds by weakening regional police powers. This happened against a wider backdrop of Moscow’s inattention and regional governments’ limited capacity or interest in addressing the crimes. The result was a rapid rise in cases, though the source stresses that exact numbers are unavailable.
The wars also drove people to flee into neighboring republics. At the same time, traditional local Islamic and ethnic leaders became more influential. Some accepted or promoted honor killings and blood feuds as ways to impose at least some control on societies described as being near complete disintegration. That response allowed violence to serve as a means of enforcing social order.
Accounts of the violence emerged, but many were dismissed as anecdotal or overshadowed by conflict and official claims of progress. Observers questioned those claims. The article places the problem especially in Chechnya, Ingushetia, and Dagestan, and says reducing it will require enormous efforts over a long period.
What could happen if the extra prison penalties for murders linked to honor killings or blood feuds were removed?
Dagestani law professor Durey Ziyadova argued that murders committed as honor killings or as part of blood feuds should be treated like all other murders. Under the system described in the article, these cases can receive additional prison time compared with ordinary murder. Ziyadova called that difference unjust, saying that murder is murder.
The figures show what could change: ordinary murder carries a sentence of six to 15 years, while murder linked to an honor killing or blood feud can carry up to 20 years. Removing the extra penalty would remove that separate, higher sentencing limit and apply the ordinary murder rules instead. The article does not give a case outcome or say how often the maximum is imposed.
The proposal sparked discussion among legal specialists and human rights activists. The article presents it as a debate over equal treatment under the law, not as a change already made. It does not establish what effect the proposed change would have on future violence or on how courts sentence individual cases.
How did Soviet policies reduce these crimes, and why did their effects not last?
The Soviet authorities treated honor killings and blood feuds as threats to their power and as “survivals of the past.” When the Bolsheviks took power in 1917, experts linked a surge in these crimes to social disruption from World War I and the Russian Civil War. The authorities blamed Islam and local traditions and responded forcefully, including by executing people they captured.
Later, the state deported nationalities most often involved and urbanized the population. The article says these steps reduced the influence of traditionalist rural communities. By the 1970s and 1980s, Moscow proclaimed victory over the practices, but the article calls that claim unjustified.
After Soviet power fell in 1991, Moscow’s inattention and regional governments’ lack of capacity or interest opened the way for cases to rise. The article says post-Soviet wars further weakened police powers. In other words, forceful suppression and social changes had reduced the crimes, but the article describes no lasting way to prevent their return when state attention and capacity weakened.
Why does a state’s ability to enforce the law matter when communities rely on customary systems to resolve conflicts?
A state’s ability to enforce law matters because it can provide an alternative to violence between families and communities. The article does not lay out a general theory of customary systems, but it describes what happened when regional police powers weakened and traditional leaders gained influence. In that setting, violence was not reliably prevented by state institutions.
After the Chechen wars, people fled into neighboring republics, police powers declined further, and traditional local Islamic and ethnic leaders became more influential. The article says some leaders accepted or promoted honor killings and blood feuds as ways to impose at least some control on societies near disintegration. This is a concrete example of customary authority being tied to violent practices, not a claim that all local leaders did so.
The article portrays these crimes as deeply rooted, particularly in Chechnya, Ingushetia, and Dagestan. It also describes regional governments as lacking capacity or interest and notes the shortage of reliable data. Reducing the violence, it argues, will require enormous, long-term effort; the source does not specify a particular enforcement policy.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web