AI-generated videos, photos alone don’t amount to forgery: HC
The Himachal Pradesh High Court ruled that merely circulating AI-generated videos or photographs said to contain false, defamatory material does not amount to forgery. It also held that police cannot use unsupported criminal charges to investigate defamation, which the court treated as a non-cognisable offence requiring a complaint before a competent magistrate. The case involved Facebook posts about a man and his family. The court found that the FIR did not allege the AI images or videos were falsely presented as someone else’s work, altered without lawful authority after creation, or obtained by deceiving someone who could not understand them. False information alone was not enough to make out forgery under Section 336(4) of the BNS. The court also found that the FIR and police status report did not explain how the posts could cause public fear or alarm. It quashed the FIR and all consequential proceedings. The ruling makes clear that alleging harmful or false content does not, by itself, establish a separate cognisable offence.
What did the Himachal Pradesh High Court decide about circulating AI-generated videos and photos?
The Himachal Pradesh High Court ruled that merely circulating AI-generated videos or photographs said to contain false, defamatory material does not amount to forgery. It also held that police cannot use unsupported criminal charges to investigate defamation, which the court treated as a non-cognisable offence requiring a complaint before a competent magistrate.
The case involved Facebook posts about a man and his family. The court found that the FIR did not allege the AI images or videos were falsely presented as someone else’s work, altered without lawful authority after creation, or obtained by deceiving someone who could not understand them. False information alone was not enough to make out forgery under Section 336(4) of the BNS.
The court also found that the FIR and police status report did not explain how the posts could cause public fear or alarm. It quashed the FIR and all consequential proceedings. The ruling makes clear that alleging harmful or false content does not, by itself, establish a separate cognisable offence.
How many people were accused, and how many criminal-code provisions were initially cited in the FIR?
The FIR named two accused people and initially cited three provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. The case began after a complaint about Facebook posts that allegedly defamed a man and members of his family. The initial provisions were Sections 351(2), 356(2) and 336(4).
Those provisions concerned criminal intimidation, defamation and forgery to harm reputation, respectively. The police registered the FIR on September 2. During the investigation, they cancelled the criminal-intimidation charge and added Section 353(1)(b), which concerns publishing or circulating false information to cause public fear or alarm.
The High Court held that the FIR and police status report did not explain how the posts could cause that fear or alarm, or induce an offence against the state or public tranquillity. It also found the forgery allegation insufficient and said police could not use unsupported offences to investigate defamation. The court quashed the FIR and all proceedings that followed from it.
What does “forgery” mean under the law, and why wasn’t allegedly false AI-generated content enough to prove it here?
In general, forgery involves making or altering a document or electronic record in a legally false way, rather than simply making an untrue statement. The article describes Section 336(4) as forgery to harm reputation and explains that the court looked for allegations about how the material was made, changed or obtained. This distinction matters because a false claim and a forged record are not the same allegation.
The Facebook posts allegedly used AI-generated videos and photographs about the complainant and his family. The court noted that the FIR did not say the material was falsely presented as having been created by someone else, altered without lawful authority after it was made, or obtained through deception from someone unable to understand its contents.
The state argued that the AI material constituted false documents. The court rejected that position on the allegations before it: saying the content was false did not establish forgery under Section 336(4). The ruling does not say that AI content can never be forged; it says the required facts were not alleged in this FIR.
What is a non-cognisable offence, and why does defamation generally require a complaint to a magistrate?
In general, a non-cognisable offence is one for which police do not have the same power to begin an investigation on their own as they do for a cognisable offence; an order from a magistrate is generally required to investigate. The article specifically states that defamation is non-cognisable and requires a complaint before the competent magistrate. This distinction limits how police may proceed in a private dispute.
The complaint in this case alleged that AI-generated videos and photographs circulated on Facebook defamed a man and his family. Police registered an FIR that included defamation under Section 356(2), along with other provisions. The High Court found that the other offences were not made out on the allegations described.
The court held that police could not investigate the defamation allegation by adding provisions that did not fit the facts. It said doing so would defeat the legislative intent that private offences should not be investigated by police. The court quashed the FIR and all consequential proceedings, while stating that defamation requires a complaint before a competent magistrate.
What would police have needed to show for the posts to count as false information likely to cause public fear or alarm?
Section 353(1)(b), as described in the article, concerns publishing or circulating false information to cause public fear or alarm. The court also referred to the need for the information to induce someone to commit an offence against the state or public tranquillity. The key issue was not only whether the content was alleged to be false, but whether the required public impact was explained.
Police added Section 353(1)(b) during the investigation. The state argued that the AI-generated material was false and could spread hatred. The police seized mobile phones, sent the videos and photographs to the state forensic science laboratory, and wrote to Facebook to identify the uploading account.
The court held that the FIR and police status report did not explain how the allegations could cause public fear or alarm, or induce anyone to commit an offence against the state or public tranquillity. It therefore found the section was not attracted on the stated facts. The court quashed the FIR and all consequential proceedings.
What happens when police add a criminal charge that does not fit the facts in order to investigate a non-cognisable offence?
The court held that an FIR cannot rely on cognisable offences that are not made out as a pretext for investigating a non-cognisable offence involving a private dispute. It said that allowing this would defeat the legislative intent that private offences should not be investigated by police. The ruling links the legal character of an offence to the limits on police investigation.
In this case, police initially registered charges that included criminal intimidation, defamation and forgery. They later cancelled criminal intimidation and added a provision about circulating false information to cause public fear or alarm. The court found the allegations did not establish forgery or explain the public fear or alarm required by the added provision.
Because the court found those other offences were not made out, police could not use them to investigate defamation under Section 356(2). It quashed the FIR and all proceedings that followed from it. The decision addresses this FIR and these allegations; it does not establish that every complaint involving allegedly false AI content must be treated the same way.
How does the law distinguish a harmful or false statement from a forged document?
The law distinguishes what a statement says from whether a document or electronic record was made or altered falsely. In general, a harmful or untrue claim may raise questions of defamation, while forgery concerns the making or alteration of a record in a legally false way. The distinction matters because the two allegations have different elements and cannot be treated as interchangeable.
Here, the complainant alleged that AI-generated posts on Facebook defamed him and his family. The court observed that the FIR did not allege the videos or photographs were falsely projected as someone else’s creation, altered without lawful authority after creation, or obtained by deception from a person unable to understand their contents.
The state argued that the material constituted false documents, but the court said that merely claiming the content contained false information was not enough for forgery under Section 336(4). It separately treated defamation as non-cognisable and held that police could not investigate it through other provisions that were not attracted. The court quashed the FIR and related proceedings.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web