JupiteX Get the app
Economy & Business22 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

The Metals Company Has a Seabed Mining Production Gap That Its Pilot Has Not Closed

The brief

TMC’s production gap is the distance between a pilot result and the hourly output its commercial targets require. In 2022, its test system collected 86.4 wet tons per hour during production runs. The company now discusses one million tons annually from an upgraded system, with still higher targets later. At 5,000 productive hours a year, one million tons requires 200 wet tons per hour. That is 113.6 tons per hour above the pilot rate, or about 2.3 times as much. The second-year target of 1.5 million tons needs 300 tons per hour; three million needs 600. The gap is not only a machine-speed question. The upgraded collector, riser, pumps and vessel must sustain output while facing maintenance, interruptions and offshore conditions. A short test rate cannot establish annual production or costs. Until TMC records enough operating hours and delivered tons, its commercial forecast rests on performance yet to be demonstrated.

01

What is the production gap between TMC’s 2022 pilot results and its proposed commercial output?

TMC’s production gap is the distance between a pilot result and the hourly output its commercial targets require. In 2022, its test system collected 86.4 wet tons per hour during production runs. The company now discusses one million tons annually from an upgraded system, with still higher targets later.

At 5,000 productive hours a year, one million tons requires 200 wet tons per hour. That is 113.6 tons per hour above the pilot rate, or about 2.3 times as much. The second-year target of 1.5 million tons needs 300 tons per hour; three million needs 600.

The gap is not only a machine-speed question. The upgraded collector, riser, pumps and vessel must sustain output while facing maintenance, interruptions and offshore conditions. A short test rate cannot establish annual production or costs. Until TMC records enough operating hours and delivered tons, its commercial forecast rests on performance yet to be demonstrated.

02

How do the pilot’s 86.4 wet tons per hour compare with the rate needed to produce one million tons a year?

The 86.4 wet tons per hour achieved in TMC’s 2022 production runs is less than half the 200 tons per hour needed for one million tons annually under the article’s operating assumption. The gap is 113.6 tons per hour.

That comparison assumes 5,000 productive hours in a year, about 57% of calendar time. At 86.4 tons an hour, 5,000 hours yields 432,000 tons. Reaching one million over the same hours requires about 2.3 times the pilot rate. The test rate shows material moved, but not that a commercial system can sustain the higher rate.

The required rate could be higher if maintenance, weather or interruptions reduce available hours. TMC expects the upgraded machines to differ from the 2022 collector, so their performance cannot be inferred from the pilot. The one-million-ton figure remains a target requiring operational proof, including sustained collection and vessel availability.

03

Why doesn’t a successful short pilot run prove that a mining system can operate commercially for a full year?

A short pilot run tests whether equipment can collect and move nodules under test conditions. Commercial production asks a different question: can the collector, riser, pumps and vessel work together reliably over many hours and through repeated maintenance cycles? That matters because annual output depends on both the collection rate and the time the system is actually operating.

The article describes a crawler working across uneven ground and varying nodule coverage, while pumps and a multi-kilometre riser handle abrasive slurry. The vessel must stay on station as crews inspect, maintain and repair equipment. Offshore access and weather affect when those jobs can happen. Each issue can interrupt production or extend downtime.

A system could meet its test rate during a run and still lose substantial productive time across a year. Repeating a successful short run does not establish annual availability, or productivity over multiple years. TMC still needs a long operating record covering maintenance, interruptions, retrieval time and delivered tons to support commercial forecasts.

04

What happens to costs per ton when maintenance and interruptions reduce the number of productive hours?

Costs per ton depend partly on how many tons share the expenses of operating offshore. If maintenance or interruptions cut production time, the system delivers fewer tons while many costs continue. That raises the cost assigned to each ton recovered and can weaken the economics of the project.

The article identifies ships, crews, marine maintenance equipment and financing as costs that continue even when nodules are not arriving on deck. For example, TMC’s August 2025 prefeasibility presentation projected offshore collection and transport at $179 per dry ton, or about $129 per wet ton using a 28% moisture assumption. Those figures are projections, not audited results from continuous industrial mining.

The actual effect of downtime has not been established by a commercial operating record. TMC would need to show productive hours, maintenance needs, rate degradation, replacement costs and delivered cost per ton. Until then, lower annual production can be understood as increasing the burden of fixed expenses, while the revised first-production configuration still needs its own cost data.

05

How is TMC’s plan to start with an upgraded pilot and invest in larger systems later meant to change its financial risk?

TMC’s phased plan begins with an upgraded pilot collector and limited modifications to the Hidden Gem, then calls for investment in larger systems as operations develop. The financial logic is to avoid committing the full amount for a larger production system at the outset. That limits the initial capital commitment while the project moves toward production.

The approach also postpones the full-scale test. TMC discusses one million tons a year from an upgraded system and eventually 12 million tons annually across four vessels. But its 2022 production-run rate was 86.4 wet tons per hour, and the upgraded machines are expected to differ. Their performance still has to be demonstrated.

Phasing therefore changes the timing and size of investment, not the need to prove the economics. TMC needs evidence on sustained rates, equipment availability, maintenance and delivered costs. The article says larger systems would be funded as operations develop, but projected commercial production remains dependent on operating results that the pilot has not established.

06

How does Impossible Metals’ autonomous-vehicle approach differ from TMC’s crawler-and-riser system?

The two approaches differ in how they gather and move nodules. TMC’s system uses a tracked crawler on the seabed, with pumps and a multi-kilometre riser carrying material up to a production vessel. Impossible Metals proposes autonomous underwater vehicles that select individual nodules and carry them in onboard cargo compartments.

In the proposed vehicle cycle, a robot descends, collects nodules, returns to the surface, is recovered, unloaded and prepared for another mission. The article’s 2025 concept described vehicles carrying 12 tons, with 18 collection arms. At one nodule every 1.5 seconds per arm and an average nodule mass of 100 grams, filling a vehicle would require roughly 120,000 successful picks; collection alone would take about 2.8 hours if all arms worked continuously.

Impossible Metals’ September 2026 trial recovered approximately 450 grams from more than 4,000 metres depth. It demonstrated selective scientific collection, but not commercial cargo capacity, cycle times or fleet availability. Both models still need evidence of sustained commercial performance.

07

What are polymetallic seabed nodules, and why are companies trying to collect them?

Polymetallic seabed nodules are rounded mineral formations on the ocean floor that contain more than one metal. The article calls them nodules but does not state their chemical composition or identify particular metals. As general background beyond the article, these nodules are commonly understood to contain metals such as manganese, nickel, cobalt and copper.

The companies discussed are developing ways to recover the nodules from the seabed. TMC and contractor Allseas tested a crawler-and-riser system, while Impossible Metals proposes vehicles that select individual nodules. The article’s focus is not the metals’ uses; it examines collection rates, equipment performance and the cost of delivering recovered material.

The commercial purpose, in broad terms, is to obtain the metals in the nodules. But the article does not give a specific market or end use, so those should not be inferred from its figures. Its central concern is whether either approach can collect enough material reliably, across sustained operations, to support projected production and costs.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web