JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance22 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Victorian Greens win injunction over how-to-vote cards mimicking party’s branding but preferencing it last

The brief

The court order stopped Finnigan’s campaign from handing out either version of its how-to-vote card. Justice John Watson granted the injunction on Sunday morning, after hearing testimony from the Victorian Electoral Commission. The decision followed the Greens’ claim that the cards could mislead voters. The first card used the Greens’ colour scheme, font and triangle logo, with the banner “Vote 1 Green Values”. It told voters to rank Finnigan first, followed by an Animal Justice party candidate, another independent and the Liberals. After the Greens threatened legal action, Finnigan changed the colours and banner, adding the words “Trans Greens Values”. The changes did not satisfy the Greens, whose lawyers sought an injunction covering both cards. Finnigan told the court they had acted quickly and lacked money to print new cards. The judge had earlier described the first card as looking like a deliberate attempt to pass as a Greens candidate. The order barred distribution of both versions.

01

What did the Supreme Court injunction stop Finnigan’s campaign from distributing?

The court order stopped Finnigan’s campaign from handing out either version of its how-to-vote card. Justice John Watson granted the injunction on Sunday morning, after hearing testimony from the Victorian Electoral Commission. The decision followed the Greens’ claim that the cards could mislead voters.

The first card used the Greens’ colour scheme, font and triangle logo, with the banner “Vote 1 Green Values”. It told voters to rank Finnigan first, followed by an Animal Justice party candidate, another independent and the Liberals. After the Greens threatened legal action, Finnigan changed the colours and banner, adding the words “Trans Greens Values”.

The changes did not satisfy the Greens, whose lawyers sought an injunction covering both cards. Finnigan told the court they had acted quickly and lacked money to print new cards. The judge had earlier described the first card as looking like a deliberate attempt to pass as a Greens candidate. The order barred distribution of both versions.

02

What is an injunction, and what does it require someone to do?

An injunction is a court order that directs a person or organisation to do something, or to stop doing something. It is a way for a court to require a particular action while a legal dispute is being considered or decided. The precise terms depend on the order; the source does not describe its duration.

In this case, the Victorian Greens asked the Supreme Court to stop independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan’s campaign handing out two how-to-vote cards. The Greens argued that the cards’ design could mislead voters into thinking Finnigan was a Greens candidate. One card copied the Greens’ branding, while the amended version changed its colours and wording.

Justice John Watson granted the injunction covering both cards on Sunday morning. That meant Finnigan’s campaign was barred from distributing either version. The decision came after the court heard testimony from the Victorian Electoral Commission. Finnigan, who represented themself, had told the court they had quickly changed the original card and did not have enough money to print new ones.

03

What is a how-to-vote card, and is it the same as the official ballot paper?

A how-to-vote card is material produced by a candidate or party that suggests an order for ranking candidates. It communicates a campaign’s preferred choices to voters. It is not itself the official ballot paper: voters use the ballot paper provided for the election to record their choices. The distinction matters because a campaign suggestion is not the same as a vote being formally cast.

Finnigan’s first card used the banner “Vote 1 Green Values” and instructed voters to put Finnigan first, followed by an Animal Justice party candidate, another independent and the Liberals. The Greens argued that its colours, font and triangle logo made the card look like Greens material. Finnigan later changed the colours and banner, but the party still went to court.

The Victorian Electoral Commission accepted Finnigan’s amended card and published it online on Friday evening. That did not end the dispute: Justice John Watson granted an injunction covering both cards on Sunday. The court decision concerned distribution of the campaign cards, not the status of a card as an official ballot paper.

04

Why did the Greens argue that the cards’ colours, logo and volunteers’ clothing could mislead voters?

The Greens argued that the cards’ appearance and the campaign’s behaviour together could confuse voters. They said people might mistake Finnigan’s material for advice from the Greens, especially when they were approaching a polling booth. The party’s leader, Ellen Sandell, said voters had already been misled by flyers and people wearing the same colour shirts as genuine Greens volunteers.

Finnigan’s first card used the Greens’ colour scheme, font and triangle logo, and carried the banner “Vote 1 Green Values”. The suggested ranking put Finnigan first and the Liberals fourth, after an Animal Justice party candidate and another independent. Greens lawyer Adam McBeth also alleged that Finnigan’s team stood near Greens volunteers and placards. The Greens said the resemblance was deliberate.

Finnigan agreed to stop distributing the first card after a legal threat and produced an amended version with different colours and a revised banner. The changes did not satisfy the Greens, who lodged papers in the Supreme Court. Justice John Watson granted an injunction against distributing both versions. Finnigan denied instructing the team to stand next to the Greens.

05

How can ranking the Liberals fourth still help them win votes as other candidates are eliminated?

In preferential voting, a voter ranks candidates rather than choosing only one. If a candidate is eliminated during the count, ballots for that candidate can be transferred to the next ranked candidate who is still in the contest. A candidate listed fourth can therefore receive a ballot’s preference later, if the choices ranked above them are eliminated.

Finnigan’s card asked voters to rank Finnigan first, followed by an Animal Justice party candidate and another independent, with the Liberals fourth. That order does not give the Liberals those ballots immediately. It can benefit them if the earlier-ranked candidates are eliminated and those ballots then move to the Liberals as the next continuing preference. The article says the card would ultimately benefit the Liberal party.

Whether that transfer happens depends on the count and on which candidates remain; fourth place alone does not guarantee a vote will reach the Liberals. The Greens were fighting to win back Prahran, which they had lost to the Liberals by a 1.3% margin in a February 2025 byelection. Labor was running an open ticket, which the Greens feared could cost them needed preferences.

06

How narrow was the Greens’ loss in Prahran at the February 2025 byelection?

The Greens’ loss in Prahran was extremely narrow: the party lost the seat to the Liberals by a 1.3% margin at a February 2025 byelection. The article describes Prahran as an ultra-marginal seat. That close result helps explain why preference votes and campaign material became such important issues in the contest.

The Greens were determined to win Prahran back. Finnigan’s how-to-vote card put the independent candidate first, then an Animal Justice party candidate and another independent, with the Liberals fourth. The Greens argued that the card’s resemblance to their branding could confuse voters about whose voting advice they were following. The party also feared that Labor’s decision to run an open ticket could deprive it of preference votes.

The Supreme Court injunction stopped distribution of both Finnigan cards after the Greens challenged them. The article does not give a result for the election or say how the preference dispute affected votes. It establishes that the Greens were campaigning to recover a seat they had lost narrowly, while seeking to protect the preferences they believed they needed.

07

What is preferential voting, and how do voters’ ranked choices help determine the winner?

Preferential voting is a system in which voters rank candidates in order of preference instead of selecting only one. As candidates are eliminated from the count, ballots can be reassigned to the next ranked candidate still in the contest. This allows a voter’s later choices to matter if their first choice does not remain in the count.

The article gives a concrete example from Prahran: Finnigan’s card asked voters to rank Finnigan first, then an Animal Justice party candidate, another independent, and the Liberals fourth. If those higher-ranked candidates were eliminated, a ballot could move to the next continuing choice, potentially the Liberals. The fourth preference does not automatically become a Liberal vote; it depends on the sequence of eliminations and the ballot’s remaining choices.

The Greens said Finnigan’s card would ultimately benefit the Liberals, who had narrowly won Prahran from them in a February 2025 byelection. The Greens were seeking to win the seat back and feared Labor’s open ticket could reduce their preference votes. The court’s injunction stopped distribution of both versions of Finnigan’s card.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web