JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance22 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Chief Justice Sharma fails to form Constitutional Bench even as cases pile up

The brief

Nepal’s Constitutional Bench is a specialised panel within the Supreme Court. Under Article 137 of Nepal’s Constitution, it consists of the chief justice and four other justices. It matters because some disputes require the court to interpret the Constitution or resolve questions that the Constitution assigns to this panel. The Constitution assigns the bench disputes about jurisdiction between the federal government, provinces and local levels. It also assigns disputes about elections to the federal Parliament or provincial assemblies, and the disqualification of their members. In addition, the bench can hear other matters set out by federal law. The chief justice designates the four justices on the Judicial Council’s recommendation. The article gives a practical example: a Supreme Court panel referred a government employees’ trade-union dispute because it raised a serious question of constitutional interpretation. The specialised bench has not been formed for around six weeks, leaving 246 petitions awaiting hearings. The article reports the delay, but does not list every category of case in the Constitution.

01

What is Nepal’s Constitutional Bench, and what kinds of cases does the Constitution assign to it?

Nepal’s Constitutional Bench is a specialised panel within the Supreme Court. Under Article 137 of Nepal’s Constitution, it consists of the chief justice and four other justices. It matters because some disputes require the court to interpret the Constitution or resolve questions that the Constitution assigns to this panel.

The Constitution assigns the bench disputes about jurisdiction between the federal government, provinces and local levels. It also assigns disputes about elections to the federal Parliament or provincial assemblies, and the disqualification of their members. In addition, the bench can hear other matters set out by federal law. The chief justice designates the four justices on the Judicial Council’s recommendation.

The article gives a practical example: a Supreme Court panel referred a government employees’ trade-union dispute because it raised a serious question of constitutional interpretation. The specialised bench has not been formed for around six weeks, leaving 246 petitions awaiting hearings. The article reports the delay, but does not list every category of case in the Constitution.

02

How many petitions are waiting for the bench, and how long has it gone without being formed?

The Constitutional Bench has 246 petitions awaiting hearings, and it has not been constituted since October 7. The article describes the standstill as lasting around six weeks. The backlog matters because these petitions are waiting for a specialised panel that handles cases involving constitutional interpretation and other matters assigned to it.

The latest example in the article is a government employee trade-union dispute. On November 17, a two-justice Supreme Court panel said the case appeared to raise a serious question of constitutional interpretation and referred it to the Constitutional Bench. That panel, however, was not available to hear the case. A separate petition on the same trade-union issue was already awaiting a verdict.

The pause followed Justice Hari Prasad Phuyal’s recusal from a case when the bench was last formed on October 7. Court holidays came next, and the bench did not resume after the Tihar break ended on November 14. Chief Justice Manoj Kumar Sharma said it would now be formed, but the article gives no date for its next sitting.

03

Why are the justices divided over how to choose the four members who would sit with the chief justice?

The article does not set out two competing proposals for choosing the four justices, so it does not fully explain a division over that process. It reports Chief Justice Sharma’s view that the Constitution requires him to sit on the bench and appoint the other justices himself. A justice on the roster, speaking anonymously, instead attributed the delay to Sharma’s lack of confidence in presiding.

The constitutional mechanism provides further context: Article 137 establishes a bench of the chief justice and four other justices. The chief justice designates those four on the recommendation of the Judicial Council. This detail comes from Nepal’s Constitution; the article’s account of Sharma’s position does not mention the recommendation step. The article says the roster includes ten justices, including the chief justice.

The reported disagreement is therefore about the deadlock and its cause, not a clearly described public dispute over rival selection rules. The roster justice said discussions had taken place between Sharma and justices close to him, but there had been no collective initiative. Sharma said the bench would now be formed, without giving a date.

04

What happened when the bench was last formed on October 7, and how did the court holidays add to the delay?

The Constitutional Bench was last formed on October 7. Its hearing was adjourned after Justice Hari Prasad Phuyal, one of the justices listed to sit, recused himself from the case. The recusal left that hearing without proceeding, and the bench was not formed again before the court’s holiday breaks.

Dashain holidays followed the adjournment. The court resumed work after that break, but the Constitutional Bench was still not constituted. It was expected to resume hearings after the Tihar holidays, which ended on November 14. Chief Justice Manoj Kumar Sharma had adopted a practice of forming the bench only on Wednesdays, so a sitting was expected on November 18.

That Wednesday passed without a Constitutional Bench. Sharma had a previously scheduled Judicial Academy programme and opted out of the day’s hearing; he said the bench could not be formed in his absence. By then, the pause since October 7 had lasted around six weeks. Sharma said all justices had returned and that the bench would now be formed, but no date was given.

05

What happens to cases that need a Constitutional Bench when it is not sitting, including the challenge to Parliament’s dissolution?

When the Constitutional Bench is not constituted, cases assigned to it cannot proceed before that specialised panel. The article reports 246 petitions waiting for hearings, illustrating how a prolonged gap leaves important disputes unresolved. It does not say that the petitions are dismissed or automatically decided while the bench is absent.

The challenge to the dissolution of Parliament is a concrete example. Around 19 petitions were registered after Prime Minister Sushila Karki recommended dissolution on September 12, 2025. The Constitutional Bench first heard the case on October 29, 2025, and issued a show-cause order. Since then, the dispute has passed through six scheduled dates without a substantive hearing.

All parties have submitted written responses, but the substantive hearing has yet to take place. The next hearing is set for January 6, 2027, after earlier dates including July 29 and September 23, 2026. The article does not predict what the court will decide. Until the bench hears the case, the constitutional challenge remains unresolved.

06

What does it mean for a court to review whether a government decision, such as dissolving Parliament, is constitutional?

Constitutional review is a court’s examination of whether a government action complies with the Constitution. The Constitution sets rules for how public power may be used, so reviewing an official decision can test whether it stayed within those rules. This is a general explanation; the article reports the challenge but does not define the legal test.

In Nepal, petitions challenged the decision to dissolve Parliament as unconstitutional. Former chief justice Sushila Karki agreed to lead a government after the 2025 protests on the condition that Parliament be dissolved immediately. She was appointed prime minister on September 12, 2025, and recommended dissolution that day. Around 19 petitions then reached the Supreme Court.

A Constitutional Bench held an initial hearing on October 29, 2025, and issued a show-cause order. The parties have submitted written responses, but there has been no substantive hearing. The next hearing is scheduled for January 6, 2027. Until the court hears the substance and issues a decision, the challenge remains unresolved; the article does not state what the outcome will be.

07

Why do constitutions divide power among the government, Parliament, and courts, and what role does that division play in limiting state power?

Constitutions commonly divide state power among institutions so that no single institution holds all authority. In broad terms, governments administer the country, Parliaments make laws and courts resolve legal disputes. This is a general constitutional principle, not a detailed explanation supplied by the article. The division matters because it creates boundaries and responsibilities for public institutions.

Courts can help enforce those boundaries by considering whether official decisions comply with constitutional rules. For example, the article describes petitions challenging the dissolution of Nepal’s Parliament as unconstitutional. The petitioners are asking the Supreme Court to assess the decision against the Constitution; the court’s Constitutional Bench issued a show-cause order after its first hearing.

That challenge has not yet received a substantive hearing, and the article does not report a ruling. Its delay shows why the bench’s ability to sit matters: a constitutional question can remain unresolved while the relevant panel is unavailable. The next hearing is scheduled for January 6, 2027. The article does not say how the court will decide or what effects its eventual decision may have.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web