JupiteX Get the app
Space22 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Which came first: black holes or galaxies?

The brief

The surprising clue is that JWST has revealed extremely massive black holes only a few hundred million years after the Big Bang. Some appear almost as massive as the stars in their host galaxies. That challenges the long-standing picture in which galaxies formed first and their black holes grew later. In nearby galaxies, a central black hole is typically about a thousand times less massive than its galaxy. But a study by Roberto Maiolino and colleagues measured the black hole in Abell2744-QSO1 and found it holds most of the object's mass. Such a large black hole so early raises questions about how quickly black holes and galaxies could grow. Astronomers do not yet know whether these outsized black holes are typical. Joseph Silk says current samples include only tens of objects, perhaps 20, 30 or 40. More JWST data could help: if black holes outweigh their galaxies increasingly far back in time, that would point toward black holes forming first. The puzzle remains open.

01

What new observations have made astronomers question whether galaxies or black holes formed first?

The surprising clue is that JWST has revealed extremely massive black holes only a few hundred million years after the Big Bang. Some appear almost as massive as the stars in their host galaxies. That challenges the long-standing picture in which galaxies formed first and their black holes grew later.

In nearby galaxies, a central black hole is typically about a thousand times less massive than its galaxy. But a study by Roberto Maiolino and colleagues measured the black hole in Abell2744-QSO1 and found it holds most of the object's mass. Such a large black hole so early raises questions about how quickly black holes and galaxies could grow.

Astronomers do not yet know whether these outsized black holes are typical. Joseph Silk says current samples include only tens of objects, perhaps 20, 30 or 40. More JWST data could help: if black holes outweigh their galaxies increasingly far back in time, that would point toward black holes forming first. The puzzle remains open.

02

What is a supermassive black hole?

A supermassive black hole is an extraordinarily massive black hole, often found at the center of a large galaxy. The article does not give a formal definition or a mass threshold. In astronomy, the term generally refers to black holes with masses millions to billions of times the sun's mass. Their size matters because they can influence the gas and star formation in their host galaxies.

The Milky Way's central black hole, Sagittarius A*, weighs over 4 million times as much as the sun. The article also notes that black holes weighing billions of suns occur in giant elliptical galaxies. These examples show that the term covers objects far more massive than black holes left by individual stars.

Astronomers are studying how such giants formed and how they affect galaxies. JWST observations have found very massive black holes early in cosmic history, including some that seem unusually large compared with their host galaxies. Scientists are still testing whether those early examples are common and how their growth relates to galaxy formation.

03

How do the masses of early black holes compare with the stars in their host galaxies and with black holes in nearby galaxies?

The key contrast is between early black holes and those in nearby galaxies. In nearby galaxies, a central black hole is typically about a thousand times less massive than its galaxy. But some early black holes appear almost as massive as the stars in their host galaxies. These comparisons suggest that the balance between black holes and galaxies may have differed in the early universe.

One example is Abell2744-QSO1. Roberto Maiolino and colleagues measured its black hole's mass directly in a study published in Nature. They found that the black hole holds most of the object's mass. That is striking because the usual nearby comparison makes the black hole a small fraction of its galaxy's mass.

The early measurements do not yet show whether this pattern is widespread. Astronomers have samples of only tens of objects, perhaps 20, 30 or 40, Joseph Silk said. More observations from JWST are needed. If black holes increasingly outweigh their galaxies farther back in time, that would suggest black holes formed first; if stars dominate, it would point the other way.

04

What are the main ways scientists think giant black holes could have formed so early?

Astronomers have several possible explanations for how giant black holes appeared so early. No single route has been confirmed, and more than one may have contributed. The possibilities matter because they could show whether black holes usually grew inside galaxies or began forming before galaxies existed.

One route starts with the remnants of massive stars. Those black holes could merge and feed on material, but in some cases they may have grown much faster than usual. Another route is direct collapse: enormous clouds of gas could collapse into black holes that are already large, giving them a head start. A third possibility is that primordial black holes formed shortly after the Big Bang, before the first stars and galaxies.

The article presents these as competing or potentially overlapping ideas, not settled answers. JWST has found very massive black holes just a few hundred million years after the Big Bang, but astronomers still need more observations to learn how common they are. Different black holes may have formed through different pathways at different times and in different environments.

05

How can a growing black hole change the gas supply and star formation in its galaxy?

A growing black hole can change the gas in its galaxy by releasing an enormous amount of energy. That energy can heat gas or push it out of the galaxy. Since gas supplies the material from which stars form, losing or heating it can curb star formation or shut it down. This feedback means black holes can influence how their host galaxies grow.

The effect is not always suppressive. A black hole's activity can also compress gas, which may trigger new stars. The article describes black holes and galaxies as influencing one another throughout their evolution, rather than acting independently. Their relationship is therefore a two-way exchange: black holes affect the conditions for star formation, while their galaxies provide the setting in which black holes grow.

The balance varies between galaxies. Joseph Silk says that in giant elliptical galaxies, black holes weighing billions of suns may have histories of extreme violence that helped limit their hosts' growth. In spiral galaxies like the Milky Way, feedback from stars tends to dominate instead. Astronomers are still investigating how these effects change over cosmic history.

06

What does it mean that these black holes existed only a few hundred million years after the Big Bang, and why is that surprising?

The finding places giant black holes in a very early chapter of cosmic history: only a few hundred million years after the Big Bang. That does not mean astronomers have watched them form. It means light from observed early-universe objects shows that massive black holes already existed by then. The timing matters because it gives black holes less time to grow than in later cosmic eras.

For decades, the prevailing idea was that galaxies came first. Black holes left by dying massive stars could then merge and feed, eventually growing to millions of times the sun's mass. But JWST observations have revealed very massive black holes surprisingly early. Some also appear almost as massive as the stars in their host galaxies, unlike the typical relationship in nearby galaxies.

Astronomers are now considering faster growth, direct collapse of enormous gas clouds, and primordial black holes as possible explanations. They do not yet know which pathway applies or whether outsized black holes are common. More JWST observations are needed to compare black-hole and stellar masses across cosmic time and test which formed first.

07

How do gas, gravity, and star formation work together to build galaxies?

The article focuses on black holes and galaxies, rather than explaining how gas, gravity and star formation build a galaxy. In general astronomy, gravity pulls gas and other matter together. As gas gathers into denser regions, it can cool and collapse further. Dense clouds can form stars, and the stars, gas and other matter together make up a galaxy.

Star formation also changes the material around it. Young stars release energy that can heat or move gas, affecting whether more stars can form. The article specifically notes that feedback from stars tends to dominate in spiral galaxies like the Milky Way. It contrasts this with giant elliptical galaxies, where black holes may have helped limit their hosts' growth through histories of extreme violence.

Gas supply matters because a growing black hole can release energy that heats or expels gas, curbing star formation. It may instead compress gas and potentially trigger new stars. So galaxy building is not simply a one-way process: gas forms stars, and stars and black holes can alter the conditions for further growth. The relative importance of these effects varies.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web