COP31 climate talks on the brink as new draft deal faces scrutiny
The draft tries to bring nearly 200 delegations together around a plan for climate action. It would acknowledge that global warming is on course to exceed 1.5°C, the limit countries had sought to preserve. It also calls for faster development of carbon-removal technologies, which could eventually reverse that overshoot. But the text avoids explicitly naming fossil fuels, which scientists say drive climate change. Instead, it refers to an earlier agreement to transition away from oil, gas, and coal. Countries also disagree over industrial carbon capture, whether new electricity should come only from renewables, and how to finance developing countries’ adaptation. Australia and Turkiye, the talks’ co-presidents, worked with delegations to produce the draft, but reactions remained divided. Turkiye’s Murat Kurum said he believed the concerns had been addressed and expected a vote later Sunday. France’s Monique Barbut called the proposal a backward step. The conference had already run past its scheduled Friday end, and a deal was not assured.
What does the new COP31 draft propose, and why is agreement on it still uncertain?
The draft tries to bring nearly 200 delegations together around a plan for climate action. It would acknowledge that global warming is on course to exceed 1.5°C, the limit countries had sought to preserve. It also calls for faster development of carbon-removal technologies, which could eventually reverse that overshoot.
But the text avoids explicitly naming fossil fuels, which scientists say drive climate change. Instead, it refers to an earlier agreement to transition away from oil, gas, and coal. Countries also disagree over industrial carbon capture, whether new electricity should come only from renewables, and how to finance developing countries’ adaptation.
Australia and Turkiye, the talks’ co-presidents, worked with delegations to produce the draft, but reactions remained divided. Turkiye’s Murat Kurum said he believed the concerns had been addressed and expected a vote later Sunday. France’s Monique Barbut called the proposal a backward step. The conference had already run past its scheduled Friday end, and a deal was not assured.
Why is the draft’s omission of an explicit reference to fossil fuels so contentious?
The draft’s omission matters because fossil fuels are at the heart of the climate problem discussed at the summit. The article says scientists identify them as drivers of climate change and as the largest contributors to it. Countries had sought language on how to wean themselves off coal, oil, and gas, so leaving those fuels unnamed affects what the deal says governments should do.
The drafts show how sharp the disagreement became. Australia’s opening proposal called for a faster phase-out of fossil fuels. A slimmer draft released Thursday removed every mention after Saudi Arabia and other major oil and gas producers objected. Observers at closed-door talks said Saudi Arabia and other producers pushed to keep fossil fuels out and carbon removal in.
The new text still refers to an earlier COP agreement to transition away from oil, gas, and coal, but that did not satisfy everyone. Environmental groups and some delegations criticized the omission. If approved, the text would offer less explicit direction on fossil-fuel efforts, while the talks’ outcome remained uncertain.
How many delegations are involved in the talks, and why can reaching agreement among so many be difficult?
Nearly 200 delegations took part in consultations involving some of the world’s richest, poorest, largest, and smallest nations. That scale matters because the agreement is meant to address how the world will respond to climate change. Reaching consensus requires governments with different circumstances and priorities to accept the same text.
The disputes in Antalya show what makes that hard. Countries differed over how much effort to make to move away from coal, oil, and gas. They also debated whether to encourage industrial carbon capture and storage, and whether rising electricity generation should rely only on renewables or include natural gas and coal. Observers said Saudi Arabia and other major oil producers pushed to keep fossil fuels out of the text.
Australia and Turkiye consulted delegations to produce a new draft, but the conference ran beyond its scheduled Friday finish. Turkiye’s president said the text could win agreement, while France’s environment minister called it a backward step. With positions still divided, the talks faced the possibility of ending without a deal.
What does the 1.5°C warming threshold mean, and why have countries sought to stay below it?
The 1.5°C threshold means a rise of 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial temperatures. The article links the figure to the 2015 Paris Agreement goal of limiting warming and says countries had sought to preserve that threshold. It is a global target, not a temperature limit for one particular day or place.
The new draft would acknowledge for the first time that the world is on course to pass 1.5°C. It also calls for faster development of carbon-removal technologies to eventually reverse the overshoot. That proposal sits alongside the draft’s omission of an explicit reference to fossil fuels, which scientists identify as driving climate change.
The article does not detail why each country adopted the limit or describe specific effects at 1.5°C. As established climate science explains, limiting warming reduces the risks of worsening climate impacts, though it does not eliminate them. The article notes that the UN expected the world would likely exceed the Paris goal, and experts said emissions need urgent, drastic cuts to avert the most catastrophic effects.
What are carbon capture and carbon removal, and how are they different from preventing emissions in the first place?
Carbon capture, as described in the article, means trapping carbon dioxide before it reaches the atmosphere. Carbon removal refers more broadly to technologies the draft encourages developing faster, with the stated aim of eventually reversing the overshoot of the 1.5°C threshold. The two terms describe different climate responses, though the article does not specify which removal methods the draft has in mind.
Preventing emissions means avoiding the release of greenhouse gases in the first place. For example, cutting the use of coal, oil, and gas reduces the emissions associated with burning those fuels. Capture tries to intercept some carbon before it enters the air; removal aims to take carbon out after it is already there. The article says experts call for urgent, drastic cuts to fossil-fuel emissions.
The draft’s support for faster carbon removal has drawn criticism from 350.org, whose representative called carbon capture a “scam.” The article does not establish that judgment as fact. It shows the broader disagreement: whether to emphasize removal and capture, direct emissions cuts, or both. Neither technology discussion resolved the draft’s contested wording on fossil fuels.
What could happen to people and ecosystems if the world does not cut climate-warming emissions quickly?
If emissions are not cut quickly, climate change can drive heatwaves, floods, and other disasters, the article says. It warns that experts believe fossil-fuel emissions must be cut urgently and drastically to avert the most catastrophic effects of warming. These risks matter because they affect communities facing increasingly damaging climate events.
The article connects the problem to coal, oil, and gas, which scientists say drive climate change. It also says the UN expected the world would likely exceed the Paris Agreement goal of limiting warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial temperatures. The draft would acknowledge that warming is on course to pass that threshold, while calling for faster development of carbon-removal technologies.
The article does not describe particular ecosystem impacts. As established climate science explains, warming can also put pressure on ecosystems, but the specific effects depend on the place and conditions. The talks’ central forward question is whether countries can agree on stronger climate action. Experts say cutting fossil-fuel emissions is urgently needed, while the draft’s omission of an explicit fossil-fuel reference remains contentious.
How does burning coal, oil, and gas trap heat in the atmosphere and cause global warming?
Coal, oil, and gas are fossil fuels. When they are burned, they release carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas that traps heat in the atmosphere. As its concentration rises, less heat escapes to space, warming the planet. This basic mechanism is established climate science; the article itself states that scientists say fossil fuels drive climate change and are its largest contributors.
The resulting warming changes the climate and drives heatwaves, floods, and other disasters, according to the article. Experts at the talks said the world needs to cut fossil-fuel emissions urgently and drastically to avoid the most catastrophic effects. This is why decisions about coal, oil, and gas are central to the draft agreement.
The negotiations show that identifying the cause does not automatically produce agreement on action. Australia’s opening draft sought a faster phase-out of fossil fuels, but a later version removed their mention after objections from major producers. The new text refers instead to an earlier agreement to transition away from these fuels. Whether countries accept that wording remained uncertain.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web