JupiteX Get the app
Environment & Climate22 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

COP’s fossil fuel consensus falls apart

The brief

COP31 was meant to advance the implementation of countries’ existing carbon-cutting commitments. Instead, negotiators could not agree on the final document’s most basic provision: what its overarching goal should be. Summit president Murat Kurum said there was no consensus, so the decisions were not adopted. The draft’s fossil-fuel language showed the divide. It merely recalled the 2023 Dubai consensus on moving away from fossil fuels, while adding calls for carbon capture. Some negotiating teams saw those calls as a way to extend fossil-fuel use. The Arab Group, China, India and Japan backed the draft; the least-developed-countries bloc, the UK and the EU opposed it. COP decisions require consensus, so support from several major negotiating groups was not enough to secure adoption. The failure marks the first unsuccessful COP conclusion since the 2009 Copenhagen summit. Countries still made progress in smaller groups: more than two dozen adopted transition guidelines, and nearly 90 signed an electrification pledge.

01

What did COP31 fail to agree on, and why was no final deal adopted?

COP31 was meant to advance the implementation of countries’ existing carbon-cutting commitments. Instead, negotiators could not agree on the final document’s most basic provision: what its overarching goal should be. Summit president Murat Kurum said there was no consensus, so the decisions were not adopted.

The draft’s fossil-fuel language showed the divide. It merely recalled the 2023 Dubai consensus on moving away from fossil fuels, while adding calls for carbon capture. Some negotiating teams saw those calls as a way to extend fossil-fuel use. The Arab Group, China, India and Japan backed the draft; the least-developed-countries bloc, the UK and the EU opposed it.

COP decisions require consensus, so support from several major negotiating groups was not enough to secure adoption. The failure marks the first unsuccessful COP conclusion since the 2009 Copenhagen summit. Countries still made progress in smaller groups: more than two dozen adopted transition guidelines, and nearly 90 signed an electrification pledge.

02

What does “consensus” mean in UN climate talks, and how can it prevent a deal from being adopted?

In UN climate talks, consensus means countries accept a decision without a country or negotiating bloc maintaining an objection that prevents its adoption. It does not necessarily mean every delegation loves every sentence or agrees with every policy. But it does mean a chair cannot simply count votes and let a majority overrule a firm objection.

That matters because countries have sharply different interests in energy and climate policy. At COP31, the draft was backed by the Arab Group, China, India and Japan, but adamantly opposed by the least-developed-countries bloc, the UK and the EU. Under the consensus rule described in the article, those opposing delegations could prevent the text from being adopted.

The result was no conference-wide decision, despite support from several large negotiating groups. Smaller agreements were still possible: countries adopted some transition guidelines and signed an electrification pledge. The article notes that consensus is especially difficult when national interests are diametrically opposed. This explanation of consensus reflects general knowledge of UN negotiations; the article itself states that COP requires it.

03

Which groups backed the draft deal and which opposed it?

The draft decision had support from several negotiating groups and countries, but not enough agreement to pass. The article names the Arab Group, which includes the UAE, as a supporter. China, India and Japan also backed adopting the draft.

Opposition came from the least-developed-countries bloc, the UK and the European Union. Their disagreement was decisive because COP decisions require consensus. The text’s weaker language on the Dubai fossil-fuel consensus and its new calls for carbon capture were especially contentious: many negotiating teams viewed carbon capture as a cover for extending fossil-fuel use.

The United States was not represented at the talks after President Donald Trump returned to office, so it is not listed among either the supporters or opponents. With the opposing blocs unwilling to accept the draft, the summit president announced that the decisions had not been adopted. Smaller groups still found common ground on fossil-fuel transition guidelines and electrification, but that did not create a conference-wide deal.

04

What was the 2023 Dubai consensus on fossil fuels, and how did its force weaken in later COP decisions?

The Dubai consensus, reached in 2023, called for a long-term phaseout of fossil fuels in the global economy. It was a significant agreement: the article describes it as the most pointed critique of the fossil-fuel industry in COP history. Oil executive Sultan Al Jaber helped bring fellow exporters on board.

The consensus proved fragile in later negotiations. At the following year’s COP in Brazil, the final deal did not include the words “fossil fuels.” Instead, it encouraged countries to take the Dubai consensus “into account” when developing national policies. That wording referred back to the commitment but did not specify an action it required.

By COP31, the draft decision only “recalled” the consensus, without saying what countries should do because of it. It also added calls for carbon capture, which many negotiating teams saw as a way to prolong fossil-fuel use. The draft failed, showing how much harder it had become to agree on common energy pathways.

05

About how much of global greenhouse gas emissions comes from burning fossil fuels?

A useful broad estimate is that fossil fuel use accounts for about three-quarters of global greenhouse gas emissions. This figure comes from established climate-science and public-information sources, not from the COP31 article, which gives no percentage. Exact estimates vary depending on which gases, sectors and emissions sources are included.

Fossil fuels are used to produce much of the world’s energy. When coal, oil or natural gas is burned, it releases carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas. Emissions from fuel use are therefore a major part of the global total. The article discusses countries’ disagreement over whether the global economy should phase out fossil fuels, but does not break emissions down by fuel or sector.

The scale helps explain why energy pathways are central to climate negotiations. Yet COP31 could not agree on a conference-wide goal, even as smaller groups pursued transition guidelines and electrification. Those efforts do not by themselves establish a global emissions share or settle how quickly countries should move away from fossil fuels. The estimate is general background, rather than a figure reported in the article.

06

What does the failure to adopt a COP-wide deal mean for countries trying to coordinate a shift away from fossil fuels?

Without a COP-wide deal, countries have no new shared decision setting the direction for a global shift away from fossil fuels. The breakdown also shows that universal agreement on energy pathways has become more elusive. That matters because countries have different views about energy security, affordability and how quickly fossil fuels should be phased out.

The COP31 draft only recalled the Dubai consensus on fossil fuels and called for carbon capture. Some teams saw carbon capture as a cover for extending fossil-fuel use, while other blocs backed the text. Because the process requires consensus, the opposing least-developed-countries bloc, UK and EU helped prevent adoption. A majority of support could not substitute for agreement.

Coordination has not stopped altogether. More than two dozen countries adopted some form of transition guidelines, and nearly 90 signed a pledge to accelerate electrification. These smaller efforts can continue, but the article says COP has become deeply fragmented. It also argues that the real economy can shape change without a UN-brokered summit setting its limits.

07

What are fossil fuels, and why does burning them contribute to climate change?

Fossil fuels are energy sources that include coal, oil and natural gas. They are called fossil fuels because they formed over long periods from ancient plant and animal material buried underground. The COP31 article discusses their role in the global economy and the dispute over phasing them out, but it does not define them; this is general scientific background.

When people burn these fuels to make electricity, heat buildings or power transport, the combustion releases carbon dioxide. That gas is a greenhouse gas: it absorbs and re-emits heat, making the atmosphere retain more warmth than it otherwise would. Other greenhouse gases also affect climate, but carbon dioxide from fossil-fuel burning is a major driver of human-caused warming.

The article describes a 2023 consensus on a long-term phaseout of fossil fuels, followed by weaker language at later COPs. At COP31, delegates could not agree on a final decision. The science explains why fuel use matters for climate change; the failed negotiations show that agreement on a shared transition remains politically difficult.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web