JupiteX Get the app
Environment & Climate22 Nov 2026 · about 8 min

COP31 climate talks break down after angry dispute over fossil fuels

The brief

COP31’s proposed agreement did not pass: after a fourth draft was rejected, President Murat Kurum said there would be no new text without consensus. The conference had officially ended Friday, but delegates kept negotiating in Antalya. The talks eventually broke down two days later, after running longer than any previous COP meeting. The disputed draft proposed measures to accelerate climate action, but omitted any reference to moving away from fossil fuels. The first draft had mentioned fossil fuels six times; the second removed every reference. The EU called the latest proposal “greenwashing,” while Panama and the Marshall Islands also rejected it as insufficient. All countries had to agree for the text to pass, and delegates could not bridge their opposing positions. Saudi Arabia, Russia and India resisted including fossil-fuel language; the EU and others wanted it. The talks ended without an overarching agreement. Kurum could convene a follow-up meeting, or decisions could be delayed until next year’s conference in Ethiopia.

01

What happened to COP31’s proposed agreement, and what key issue helped bring the talks to a halt?

COP31’s proposed agreement did not pass: after a fourth draft was rejected, President Murat Kurum said there would be no new text without consensus. The conference had officially ended Friday, but delegates kept negotiating in Antalya. The talks eventually broke down two days later, after running longer than any previous COP meeting.

The disputed draft proposed measures to accelerate climate action, but omitted any reference to moving away from fossil fuels. The first draft had mentioned fossil fuels six times; the second removed every reference. The EU called the latest proposal “greenwashing,” while Panama and the Marshall Islands also rejected it as insufficient.

All countries had to agree for the text to pass, and delegates could not bridge their opposing positions. Saudi Arabia, Russia and India resisted including fossil-fuel language; the EU and others wanted it. The talks ended without an overarching agreement. Kurum could convene a follow-up meeting, or decisions could be delayed until next year’s conference in Ethiopia.

02

Why did the draft’s removal of references to fossil fuels matter to the EU and other countries?

For the EU and other countries, fossil-fuel language was central to whether the proposed agreement matched the scale of climate action they wanted. The draft set out measures to accelerate action, but made no mention of moving away from fossil fuels. EU representative Darragh O’Brien said the bloc strongly objected and called the text “greenwashing.”

The change was stark: the first draft mentioned “fossil fuel” or “fossil fuels” six times, while the second draft removed every reference. The latest draft still had none. The concern was not only about wording: at COP28, countries had agreed for the first time to “transition away” from fossil fuels in energy systems. The draft recalled that agreement but did not repeat its key phrase.

The omission helped prevent consensus. Saudi Arabia, Russia and India opposed including the words, citing financial risks to economies reliant on fossil fuels. The EU and other nations objected that a pact with no mention of fossil fuels lacked ambition. With every party’s agreement required, the divide left the draft unable to pass.

03

How many countries took part in the talks, and did every party have to agree for the text to pass?

Delegates from 196 countries and the European Union took part in the Antalya talks. That made the negotiations a major international effort, but participation did not guarantee an agreement. The delegates had to settle on a shared text covering new climate pledges and how to deliver on previous promises.

The rule was decisive: all countries had to agree on the text for it to pass. The article does not say that a majority vote could replace consensus. In practice, proposals had to be acceptable to all parties, even when their priorities differed. The draft’s lack of fossil-fuel references drew objections from the EU and other nations, while several countries opposed including such language.

That disagreement remained unresolved in the fourth draft, which was rejected. COP31’s talks continued beyond the scheduled Friday end and became the longest in COP history, but no agreement emerged. The conference involved 196 countries plus the EU as a participant; the text still needed every country’s agreement to pass.

04

How does a consensus rule give each delegation influence over a climate agreement?

Consensus means the proposed text must be acceptable to all countries taking part. COP31’s article states that all countries had to agree for the text to pass. This makes negotiations depend on finding language that the delegations can support, rather than simply counting which side has more votes.

The practical effect is that a delegation can withhold agreement when it considers an issue a red line. At Antalya, Chris Bowen described “unbridgeable red lines.” The EU objected to the draft’s silence on fossil fuels, while Saudi Arabia, Russia and India pushed back on including any reference to them. With no shared wording, the draft could not pass.

The rule gives every delegation influence, but it can also make agreement difficult when positions conflict. COP31’s fourth draft was rejected, and Kurum said no new text would be prepared without consensus. The talks ended without an overarching outcome. The article says a follow-up meeting could be convened, or decisions could wait until next year’s conference in Ethiopia.

05

What could happen as global warming goes beyond 1.5°C?

The article warns that as global warming goes beyond 1.5 degrees Celsius, the impacts of climate change are expected to ramp up significantly. That matters because the effects are not described as a distant abstraction: the article specifically points to extreme heat and other weather events as harms expected to intensify.

The 1.5-degree figure is the temperature goal set by the 2015 Paris Agreement: keeping the rise in global temperatures below that level. COP31’s latest draft acknowledged that the goal is going to be missed. The article does not give a detailed forecast for particular places or types of weather, so it supports a broad warning rather than a precise local prediction.

The talks’ collapse does not change the science, United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres said, even though there was no negotiating consensus. If warming moves beyond the threshold, the article says climate impacts are expected to grow significantly. It does not specify how quickly they will intensify or set out a separate response plan.

06

What does the Paris Agreement’s 1.5°C goal measure, and why is that threshold important?

The Paris Agreement’s 1.5°C goal is a limit for the rise in global temperatures. The article describes the 2015 agreement as aiming to keep that rise below 1.5 degrees Celsius. It does not specify the reference period used to measure the increase, so the key point here is the global temperature rise and the agreed threshold.

That threshold matters because the article links warming beyond 1.5°C with more severe climate impacts. It names extreme heat and other weather events, which are expected to ramp up significantly as warming goes beyond the goal. This is why the target is more than a number in a climate agreement: it marks a level beyond which the article expects impacts to worsen.

COP31’s latest draft acknowledged that the goal is going to be missed. The talks still failed to reach consensus on an overarching outcome, but Guterres said that did not create ambiguity in the science. The article gives no specific new temperature forecast or timeline for crossing the threshold.

07

What are fossil fuels, and how does burning them contribute to global warming?

Fossil fuels are energy sources such as coal, oil and natural gas. The article does not define them, so this explanation uses well-established scientific knowledge beyond the article. They formed from ancient organic matter over long periods and are burned to provide energy for electricity, transport and other uses.

When fossil fuels burn, they release carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas. Greenhouse gases trap heat in the atmosphere, contributing to global warming. That is why language about moving away from fossil fuels can be important in climate discussions. The article notes that countries at COP28 agreed for the first time to “transition away” from fossil fuels in energy systems.

At COP31, the latest draft made no mention of fossil fuels, despite the EU and other countries demanding such language. Saudi Arabia, Russia and India pushed back, citing financial risks because fossil fuels are central to their economies. The dispute over whether to name them helped prevent countries from reaching consensus on a new agreement.

08

What does “greenwashing” mean, and why did the EU use that term to describe the draft agreement?

In common usage, “greenwashing” means presenting an action, product or policy as environmentally responsible while its substance does not support that impression. The article does not define the term, so this explanation draws on well-established general usage. The EU used it to criticize the proposed agreement’s apparent climate ambition.

The draft set out measures for countries to accelerate climate action, but contained no mention of moving away from fossil fuels. That omission mattered to the EU and other nations, who regarded fossil-fuel language as essential. Darragh O’Brien, representing the EU, called the deal “greenwashing” and said its decisions fell far short of the ambition needed to tackle climate change.

The dispute was part of a wider divide. Saudi Arabia, Russia and India opposed including any reference to fossil fuels, citing financial risks to their economies. Because all countries had to agree, objections on both sides could not be resolved in the fourth draft. The draft was rejected, and COP31 ended without consensus on an overarching outcome.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web